The Pizza Lady — Restaurant in Stonington

Well, one thing that can be said is that this is NOT the Pizza Lady most of us spent the last 35ish years loving. I’ve given it three chances since ownership change. It’s just not the same, not even close. I was unimpressed when I walked in to hear the gal taking orders being absolutely rude to the woman ordering over a simply food delivery question. Lady behind the counter, work on your delivery. Work on your skills dealing with your clients. I’ll be respectful and not drop names. Moving on to my food experience…Our order consisted of a chicken caesar wrap. The wrap was poorly constructed. More like salad wrapped in paper. Soggy lettuce, flavorless shredded chicken. Dressing has good flavor but tossed the rest as I wasn’t going back in for a fork to eat my wrap. We ordered a chicken cutlet grinder for my coworker. The cutlet grinder ended up as a chicken parm, ok mistakes happen. The chicken was only a step or two above the quality of kids Dino nuggets. And about equivalent portion wise to about five Dino nuggets. The sauce was pedestrian at best. Not horrible but not very good at all. I did grab a slice of meatball pizza. It was what you’d expect from a slice that’s been in the warning case. I’m ok with that, sauce is clearly the same as that used in the chicken parm.

The positives, our coke zeros were cold and the deep river chips weren’t expired so that’s a plus.

Going forward, the place is a hard pass. Very disappointing and not even a shadow of what pizza lady once was. Without DT, this place just doesn’t make the mark anymore. Place needs to make a name change as it doesn’t do the long loved Pizza Lady name any justice, simply an impostor.

Peace out Pizza lady....

So... catering plans didn't work out for my youngest girl's birthday party, we found ourselves floundering one day before the party to get food together for a bunch of little kids and discerning parents / grandparents. Enter Tony at The Pizza Lady, who stepped in with less than twenty four hours and set us up with a KILLER spread at a very reasonable price. Food was amazing (honestly, the kids chicken tenders were delicious.... I didn't know tenders could taste like that), Tony had everything ready for us by 10:30 am, and he was ready to send more pizza if we underestimated how much food we'd need. I know listeners like when we tell Dad Fails on the podcast, but this was a Dad Win. Solved the problem, showed up with the goods for the kiddo's birthday, Dad Hero Status achieved. Thanks Tony and The Pizza Lady for giving me the cape...

Ive been coming here for 30 years and recommended this spot to friends and customers my entire time in business. Today they lost a lifelong customer. We ordered a soupy with peppers and onion for lunch, standard i would assume as ive ordered it many times before with zero incident. Well, they forgot the Soupy which is already questionable enough. Im not judging you if you order pepper and onion plain but it doesn't seem like it would be a popular one to me. Anyway THEY ASKED FOR THE PIZZA BACK.. that's right, they made us return a pizza half eaten in order to redeem the original pizza we ordered. No apology, no discount, no offer to fix. What are you guys doing with that pizza?? Strange and unacceptable. I'll be taking my business to Main St...