Your Pie — Restaurant in Toccoa

I’ve been a long time Your Pie fan at other locations so I’m excited they’re in Toccoa. Okay experiences so far but not great. Two times ago I visited and they forgot my food. Someone from my table let them know when the rest of my party was basically done eating. We were made to feel like it was our fault somehow for it not coming out to us even though my number was still sitting clearly on the table. Today, it wasn’t my food but another member of my party’s food was forgotten. He asked for no olives and got olives. Same thing happened to him after visiting last night (olives when no olives requested). The worst thing was someone in our party ordered the lemon ricotta chicken pizza. Nothing was said when she ordered it, but when they brought it out they said, “We actually don’t have any lemons because we’re not making this pizza any more.” Why didn’t anyone say that when she ordered? My hope is that this crew finds their stride and can make this place great. Toccoa...

Grand opening of Toccoa Your Pie was today (5/2/2025). Flawless service and excellent food. Finally, Toccoa has something in downtown that is new and different and a great reason to visit the downtown area. Thank you to the owners of Your Pie and Toccoa for making this happen. I hope they are in business for MANY years to come.

NOTE: This is a NEW business, just open a little under a week. Like all new businesses, there are growing pains and training situations. All the bad reviews they have received in the past week are UNWARRANTED. This place is great, they are working really hard, and the food is delicious. Just because a few haters decided to review bomb them all on the same day with a bad review should be 100% overlooked. These people are just miserable and shouldn't be allowed to do this. YOUR PIE...

Just Edible pizza. But that’s about it. The reasons I ever would go to any YourPie location (Clarkesville, Clemson) were just not here in Toccoa. You can’t watch over the making of your pizza on the line. That was almost the entire point, being able to advise the creating of your pizza. “Oh maybe a little less pepperoni.” “Could I actually have more mushrooms?” It is YOUR freaking PIE. Toccoa location does not have that personal aspect. It doesn’t feel like MY pie anymore. The interior design and atmosphere doesn’t feel very upbeat like other locations. And the crust is pretty bland. It tastes like it needs more salt. Again, somehow Clarkesville and Clemson locations crust tastes good especially for thin crust. I think the Toccoa location has just lost the roots and special feeling that other YourPie...