Gino's NY Pizza ( University Plaza ) — Restaurant in Town of Amherst

As a transplant from NYC, I am always on the lookout for “NY style” pizza in WNY. We went to a movie in the same shopping center and were excited to try Gino’s for dinner when we saw it. I’m glad we tried it but I’m in no rush to go back. It wasn’t the most pleasant place to dine-in at as the store and tables were very messy and the chairs were all so worn and ripped. At one point, a young male employee was talking to another employee and using some obscenities. We didn’t clutch our pearls about it but we both noted to one another that it was off putting. As for the food, it was decent. The sauce is definitely a bit of a compromise between “NY style” and the sweeter sauce preference of the region, which isn’t unfair. The garlic knots had ok flavor but I did appreciate they were very soft and not too tough. Overall, it was a decent place to eat but I would only get takeout...

We hadn't ordered from here in a while so the other night we decided to try them out again, paid $43 for a "large" pizza, 10 wings and mozzarella sticks, the pizza had pepperoni, mushrooms and extra cheese. The toppings weren't bad, but the dough was horrible like eating tough leather and the large pizza was more like a medium pizza, I remember it being much bigger. The wings were also terrible they were so small and tough to eat like they had been heated and reheated 3 or 4 times and there was a ton of sauce on them. We ended up throwing most everything out. The only thing that was good were the mozzarella sticks. There were 6 of them and my husband and I were laughing because we were fighting over them!! That's mostly all we had for dinner. Do not order from here!! I'm very suspicious of the 5 star ratings that's all I'm...

Really great delivery folks. The food was really gross though. Pizza was overcooked and tough- cheese was scarce at best . The bottom crust was chewy and burnt. Bbq Wings were overcooked, dry and stringy. Very little meat. :/ I typically like this place- with not so great situations regarding food here and there...but I am kind of annoyed that I spent over $80 yesterday evening for poorly prepared food. Chicken fingers were ok. ..fries were really soggy and tasteless. I put them in my air fryer and seasoned them. 70% better. I wish I could have just cooked if I was able. But I simply wasn't and that was why I relied on this resturant. I will pass on them moving forward. A refund or at least a partial refund would be great but I'm sure that won't happen...although it's extremely...