Gemelli's Gourmet LI — Restaurant in Town of Babylon

This gourmet deli is an absolute standout! From the moment you walk through the door, you’re met with a warm, inviting atmosphere and a team of genuinely friendly staff who make you feel right at home. Their passion for great food and great service is obvious from the start.

The menu is a dream for anyone who loves fresh, high-quality ingredients. The sandwiches are expertly crafted with thoughtfully chosen combinations—think artisan breads, premium meats and cheeses, house-made spreads, and crisp, vibrant veggies. Each bite is bursting with flavor and feels like it was made just for you. The salads are just as impressive—fresh, colorful, and perfectly balanced with bold flavors and just the right amount of creativity.

The deli itself is spotless and inviting. Clean counters, a well-organized display, and a cozy, modern atmosphere make it a pleasure to dine in or grab something to go. You can tell this place is run with care and attention to detail.

Highly, highly recommend. Whether you're a sandwich connoisseur or just need a quick, satisfying lunch, this Italian deli hits the mark every time. A new...

I grabbed a pick up order for me and my boys, we got the Po Boy, Polar Bear, Brisky, and the Smoke Up. Five sandwiches took less than thirty minutes, mind you. This is by far the best lunch we’ve had in a while. I kid you not, I got the Po Boy, I have tried authentic New Orleans Po Boys before, and I swear on everything I have, that this sandwich is actually BETTER than the real thing. AFTER ONE BITE, I can say with confidence that the shrimp was perfectly cooked, the sauce coats everything with PRECISION, not too much, but plenty to get a burst of flavor in every bite. I couldn’t praise this place more. The staff are also some of the nicest people I’ve had the pleasure of meeting, each of them greet you with a smile that tells you that you’re about to have a really freaking good day. Normally, $16 for a sandwich isn’t something I would pay for, but Gemelli’s is the exception, I would GLADLY take every cent i have for another sandwich from here.

5/5 stars aren’t enough to truly grasp how good...

My go to place for sandwiches and sides!!! I’ve been to Gemelli’s six times since they’ve opened. The staff is extremely kind and professional. They work as efficiently as they can given the volume and the fact that they freshly slice the meats for the sandwiches. The shop itself is spotless. The stracci chachi and the godfather are the two sandwiches I alternate between. In terms of portion size, they are perfect to share for two people. If the bread that the sandwich is traditionally on is not what you want, you can switch it. I probably would disregard any one star reviewers in this thread considering they only have two reviews. The other one being a five star review for the Gemelli’s in Babylon. I suspect it’s a troll who is affiliated with that location and is just jealous that this location is thriving. Keep doing what you guys are doing! Best deli in...