Mayfair Bagel Cafe Too! — Restaurant in Town of Brookhaven

Absolutely Fantastic Spot!

Mayfair Bagel Cafe Too! is hands down one of the best local bagel shops I’ve ever been to. From the moment you walk in, you’re greeted with a cozy, welcoming atmosphere and staff that genuinely care about their customers. They’re friendly, fast, and always get the order right—even during the busy morning rush.

The bagels here are on another level—crispy on the outside and perfectly soft and chewy inside. You can tell they’re fresh and made with care. I got the egg sandwich on a toasted everything bagel, and it was absolutely perfect. The eggs were fluffy, the cheese was melted just right, and the whole thing was stacked and satisfying. Also tried their coffee, and it was surprisingly good—rich and smooth, not your average diner coffee.

Their prices are super reasonable for the quality and portions you get. For under $10, you walk away full and happy. This place also shines when it comes to cleanliness—everything from the counter to the tables is always spotless.

Whether you’re grabbing a quick breakfast or a casual lunch, this spot delivers every time. Highly recommend it if you’re in the area and looking for a classic New York bagel shop that does...

Sunday brunch just hit different here. Came by with the family the other day for a casual breakfast, and let me tell you — it was anything but ordinary.

First off, the place is spotless. Like, your mom-would-approve level clean. You can tell they actually care about hygiene — and not just the kind that gets posted on a sign.

The staff? Friendly, upbeat, and genuinely seem like they enjoy being there (which, let’s be honest, is rare these days).

Coffee? On point. Prices? Let’s just say my wallet didn’t cry for once. And the omelets? Honestly… if I were Zagat or Michelin, I’d be handing out stars like bagels on a Sunday morning.

This is exactly the kind of spot Long Island needs more of — real, warm, and worth the visit. Thank you, Corner Bagel. We’ll be back — probably way...

For starters…excellent bagels, the amount of seeds on these is like something i’ve never seen before at another store.

Next, this owner does an EXCELLENT job at picking out his staff. I went on the weekend and there was this young man who provided me and my family excellent service. We ordered like 7 bagels and somehow he did made them and put them in a bag in I think under 2 minutes? When we all opened them at the beach later they were genuinely made perfectly, perfect amount of cream cheese (not too much or too little) and they were so neat.

Great food, amazing service, bagels are...