Premiere Pastry Shop — Restaurant in Town of Brookhaven

If I have one regret, it’s not discovering this hidden gem three years ago when I first moved to Long Island. Premiere Bakery isn’t just a bakery—it’s a feeling, a memory, a warm embrace disguised as a neighborhood shop.

Stepping inside is like visiting a beloved uncle back home, the kind who greets you with a beaming smile, a hug, and a cup of coffee and fresh bread before you even place an order. There’s no rush here. You take your time, letting the aroma of freshly baked goods guide you as you browse the shelves, knowing full well that the tres leches cake is coming home with you—because at this point, it’s tradition.

But Premiere is more than just its pastries. It’s a safe haven. A place where warmth isn’t just in the bread, but in the way Niko and Katia welcome you as if you’ve been coming for years. Where a simple transaction turns into an exchange of kindness, conversation, and maybe even a complimentary cup of coffee.

In a world where authentic, family-run bakeries are becoming rare, places like Premiere feel almost sacred. So, visit when you have time—because you won’t just leave with pastries. You’ll leave with a heart full of warmth and the kind of human connection that makes...

I decided to stop by after my dentist appointment after being enticed by the smell. The gentleman was very nice and greeted me when I entered. Though I was not impressed with the amount of selection, most likely due to the pandemic; I decided to give the bakery a try half-heartedly. Well, am I so very elated that I did. I selected the chocolate cigar and crumble apple cake and am completely blown away by how absolutely delicious they both were. I almost couldn't save enough of the chocolate cigar for my husband; he only got two bites before I devoured it. The apples in the apple pie were moist and crisp. I was speechless!! How did they do that!? My friends were even surprised at the quality of the taste.

I HIGHLY RECOMMEND THIS PASTRY SHOP AND WILL BE VISITING VERY...

I absolutely love this pastry shop! Their service is AMAZING, and their pastries not only look mouth-watering, but also taste DELICIOUS!

I've followed their social media account for a while and was dazzled by how good the pastries looked. I finally decided to go to the shop and was pleased to discover it lived up to my expectations. Everything tasted SO good! On top of that, it was lovely to see the talent and passion of the staff. They were beyond kind, and really make sure to please their customers and offer a great experience.

I recommend the macaroons, cakes, cannolis, cookies and...