D'Agostino's Pizzeria Inc. — Restaurant in Town of Cheektowaga

Gave them 2 tries: Food was just decent, not great. 3.5 stars for the food. Pizza crust is stale tasting, not sure how to describe it... but everything else tasted good. More importantly, though, while it is impossible to social distance inside their storefront due to its small size, one day during rush there were 6 employees all in a small area with none wearing masks on their faces, and the second time during a slow afternoon there were 3 employees, again, no masks, except for the person cashing me out which put it up for about 5 seconds, it fell back down, and he left it down. Also lots of flies flying around. Won't go back for a 3rd try; just not worth it. There are better spots...

I've gone to D'Agostino's for over 14 years now, and I've still never had a better pizza. The taste, ingredients, and proportions are always masterfully combined into a perfect pizza by the professionals that work there, along with the chicken wings that had numerous varieties of spiciness and flavor (depending on what you order). Through all these years I've not received an incorrect order. The staff is very friendly and welcoming and will likely even memorize you along with common orders you place. All of this is done in a short amount of time and yet its still perfect in every way. I highly recommend D'Agostino's in small, personal sizes, as well as for families and full...

What is wrong with kids these days? I just ordered an expensive pizza, with 2 cups of anchovies on the side, a toping wich no one ever orders except me I'm sure, they charge me full price for 2 servings and each cup only had 3 anchovies in them, I'm no pizza expert but both the cups weren't even enough for one slice, I called and demanded my money back for them and they said they would only refund me a dollar when they charged me full for the 2, then I said, I want to be re embursed for my blue cheese.... he said no, why would I do that you got you blue cheese right? I said call it an inconvenience fee... is this how you treat customers? I will be there first thing...