SugarHi | Cakes & Dessert | Ice Creams & Candies — Restaurant in Town of North Castle

I placed my Thanksgiving order knowing the bakery was 45 mins away, but I was impressed with the reviews and social media presentations. Sadly it wasn’t worth the hype for me. I ordered a cake and pumpkin pie and purchased additional sugar cookies in store when I arrived. The cake was average at best, pumpkin pie good, the 6 cookies I purchased for $27 in store were crack your teeth, rock hard. I attempted eating one on the way home, but was honestly afraid of the dental bill.. I could barely bite them. When I finally got back to NJ my kids immediately went wanted the cookies and turned them down after attempting to bite them. The employees weren’t very friendly which was a surprise given the fact they spend money on targeted social media.. why do that, if your employees don’t love...

Our cake not only looked beautiful but tasted even better! We loved all the details that went into the cake and couldn’t believe how well they listened to what we wanted. The color and pictures were exactly what we wanted and couldn’t be happier with how everything turned out. Guests from the party were raving about how delicious the cake was the next day and we will definitely be using sugar-hi again in the future for our next event. We had the cookies and cream filling and it honestly was the best cake I think I have ever had. The buttercream frosting was just sweet enough and everything was fresh. Thank you for putting so much thought into our cake and helping make the day that...

Large selection of baked goods and ice cream. Bakery items were fresh and had an interesting "homemade" twist to them. However, even though this place is aimed at kids they weren't very friendly to my excited 2 year old, who was amazed at all the goodies. The seating area is small and a bit cramped for any moms looking to bring in a stroller. While my daughter enjoyed her ice cream, the treats we brought home were super super sweet. They were so sweet that we took a few bites and discarded them. TIP: If you're making the trip to visit them and can, try to do so before school dismissal as it was extra crowded with youngsters who had just...