Bayville Deli & Pizzeria — Restaurant in Town of Oyster Bay

They're this huge written out sign do not read newspaper unless your going to buy it. Omg what is it a dollar? With all the business we the locals give you, while we wait can't look at paper and put it back? Also the pizza man said we have no condiments salt, pepper,garlic powder. Huh that's pennies . Thee owners are super good people I know but please we the small community give alot. Looking at a paper or asking for salt shouldn't be a problem for a...

Firstly, all the guys at the pizza counter are always nice, but the staff at the checkout counter definitely hate their job. I've been here multiple times wanting to like it but I didn't like any of the sandwiches or pizzas. :( The prepared cold salads and soup was good, though. Also the prices seem to fluctuate pretty often, so just keep...

This cozy spot in Bayville offers a charming community atmosphere, often frequented by friendly older folks who enjoy cracking jokes. It adds to the experience! You can even play the New York Lottery while enjoying some pizza. However, if this place is closed, it might be best to head home or order from nearby options through food...