Buffalo Wild Wings — Restaurant in Town of Oyster Bay

I live about 6 minutes from this place and my boyfriend and I eat here often because of the location and convenience to run errands. But the service we received yesterday was the worst I've dealt with in a restaurant in a looooong time. It was happy hour, which we knew because of how often we go, but not once have we ever heard of the limitation that it includes only "short" beers. My boyfriend double checked that it was still happy hour with our waitress and she confirmed it was and my boyfriend went on to order a tall of the 'beer of the month'. Not once did she say "just so you know happy hour only includes shorts, not talls" despite knowing we were interested in happy hour specials. She seemed irritated and like she was rushing us along right from the start. When she gave us our bill we were shocked. $8.50 for the beer that we thought was a part of happy hour. When we asked her about it he response was short and unpleasant; "well you ordered a tall and I just gave you what you wanted" and my boyfriend replied with "don't you think you could have told me it was only shorts?" And she said "oh well". We paid and left angry while the waitress talked to two managers and watched us leave visibly upset. 2 minutes later we decided to go back in and talk to a manager. Her attitude was almost no better. She listened to the complaint and replied with "well, I don't know what to do for you", walked away, talked to another manager and asked if we wanted a $5.00 gift certificate. Meanwhile the beer was almost 8! I guess she decided against that and gave us a $10 one. She admitted that maybe the waitress did that to jack up the bill, which was weird for a manager to say about her employee. Overall, we were disappointed and plan on going to the westbury...

When we walked in the hostess was talking to a co-worker. Needless to say we didn’t interrupt their conversation as we waited patiently to be even acknowledged. The place was empty aside from a handful of tables with patrons scattered around the room. You’d expect the hostess to greet people as soon as they walked in, pause their conversation and seat them as soon as possible given “you have one job” primarily as a hostess.

After being seated our waitress came by to ask for our drink order. When I asked if there was a cocktail menu I was told no, she mentioned two drinks which didn’t interest me so I just ordered a cola. When she walked away my spouse found the cocktail menu inside the dinner menu.

I ordered the “Tito’s Wild Bloody Mary” only to be told later that they ran out of “Bloody Mary mix”. I then ordered the “Modelo Michelada” that I did enjoy.

We ordered the “Buffalo Chicken Tater Tots” that we later discovered did not contain buffalo sauce. We were then told by our waitress it had bbq sauce and “mild” sauce. It must have been REALLY mild, because I didn’t taste anything but BBQ sauce. The Asian Zing boneless chicken taste like frozen nuggets covered in a teriyaki type spicy sauce & very disappointing.

We have gone to other Buffalo Wild Wing establishments so this doesn’t reflect our usual experience. Also, I don’t go out of my way to write scathing reviews. Google Maps popped up a request for a review and since I was so disappointed, I decided to share. Be careful what you ask for Google Maps.

I hope for BWW’s sake this was a “one off” and others have better experiences than we...

A Go-To Spot for Wings, Sports, and Fun

We’ve been coming to this Buffalo Wild Wings location for years, and it’s been consistently a great place to relax, eat, and have a good time. Whether it’s catching a big game, enjoying a night of trivia, or just meeting friends for happy hour, this place has delivered every time.

⸻

Sports & Atmosphere

The setup here is perfect for sports fans — screens everywhere, so you never miss a play no matter where you sit. The energy during big games is electric, with fans cheering, servers hustling, and that unmistakable buzz of game day excitement.

⸻

Food & Promotions

Over the years, we’ve taken advantage of some great wing promotions, especially during games, and they’ve always been fresh, hot, and loaded with flavor. The variety of sauces and seasonings keeps things interesting — whether you’re into blazing heat or tangy and mild, there’s something for every taste.

⸻

Drinks & Happy Hour

Their happy hour deals on drinks make it easy to stick around and enjoy the night. Cold beers, good cocktails, and reasonable prices have kept us coming back.

⸻

Trivia Nights & Entertainment

Trivia nights here are a lot of fun — lively, well-run, and a great way to spend an evening with friends. Add in the food and drinks, and it’s an easy choice for a weeknight out.

⸻

Overall: This Buffalo Wild Wings has been a reliable go-to for us, and it’s more than just a place for wings. It’s a spot for sports, laughter, and good times — the kind of place that makes you want to come back...