Casa Stellina Ristorante — Restaurant in Town of Oyster Bay

The food was good. The ambience good be great if they change a couple things. They need more wait staff on Saturday night. Our waiter was rushing the entire night. Didn’t get to show personality as it was: take the drink order, take the order, drop the desert menu, drop the check. I felt bad for the guy as promptness and attending to too many was his only concern. The bus staff was excellent. Played cleared, waters filled promptly, very attentive. Our waiter behaved like bus staff. Give him some help so he can relax a little and enjoy the guests. The manager was excellent, polite, and seemed like he cared. The other thing to fix: keep large parties away from small parties or just don’t book large at all. This could be a romantic dining spot but it has no chance. There appears to be some private areas near the back. Stuff large parties over there. Quaint areas with romantic ambience should be reserved for tables of 2-4. When you get these large parties, it’s very noisy and now it sounds like a sports bar. So let large parties sit with large parties so they can out-yell each other and don’t understaff Friday and Saturday and I think this cute restaurant could be 5 Star, and a top date-night venue. $175 without tip or tax for two with app, wine, cocktail, and entree....

Casa Stellina is an absolute gem of an Italian restaurant that delivers an unforgettable dining experience from start to finish. The atmosphere is warm, welcoming, and full of charm, making you feel like you’ve been transported straight to a cozy trattoria in Italy. But the real magic happens on the plate—especially when it comes to their legendary chicken parmesan. This dish is, hands down, one of the best you’ll ever taste. The chicken is perfectly breaded and fried to a golden crisp, yet incredibly tender and juicy on the inside. It’s smothered in a rich, flavorful marinara sauce and topped with a generous layer of gooey, melted mozzarella that stretches with every bite. Paired with their house-made pasta or garlic-kissed vegetables, it’s comfort food elevated to a whole new level. Every dish at Casa Stellina is made with fresh, high-quality ingredients and the kind of care that only comes from a genuine passion for Italian cooking. From the appetizers to the desserts, everything bursts with authentic flavor. The staff is friendly, attentive, and knowledgeable, always making you feel like family. If you’re craving a hearty, satisfying meal in a beautiful setting, Casa Stellina is the...

Very difficult place to give a review. Food was awesome. Great flavor and cooked perfect, but for what they charge for the meals definitely overpriced and not worth it at all. Chicken cutlet parm was really good but for $39 I was expecting more than literally 1 piece of chicken with sauce and cheese. No soup, salad, side of pasta nothing. Appetizers were very small which I understand there not supposed to be big but we got 2 appetizers for 4 people counting myself and we all took 1 bite of each and that's it. Service was ok, not great but not bad. Waiter and even bus boys were on the money with taking plates away and refilling drinks but when you say thank you or please there answer is "yup" and seem very miserable while working. Also the waiter didnt explain anything when asked what he thought about select items. I got the "im better than you" stuck up vibe and im an easy person to get along with, ive been told. Atmosphere was very nice and very delicate, beautiful setting. For the money that was spent for our first time going there we WONT be returning. Mezza luna blows this place out of the water without a doubt with serving size, flavor of food...