Stuff-A-Bagel Bethpage — Restaurant in Town of Oyster Bay

Complete waste of time in my opinion. The credit card minimum is ridiculous considering they are already charging a fee on top for using the credit card. Had to give them $100 bill at 6am for a 4$ bagel. And they had the nerve to ask me if I had a smaller bill. That’s the whole reason for using my card. I’ve also had multiple ordered a screwed up and had to go back and have them redone still to be done wrong. Imagine walking back to your car after you just drive back from your house for the second time and open your order and it’s wrong again. It’s like they don’t understand the English language. They also charge for the smallest thing alike toasting a bagel is a 15 cent charge. Im sorry but when you start nit picking for an item that is constantly being used, you should get out of the business. It should be priced into the bagel already. I never checked but I bet they charge for the ketchup on a bacon egg and cheese as well. I stopped going to this place after the last incident with the credit card ordeal. If you don’t want people to review their extremely poor experience at your establishment then maybe you should consider improving your employees work ethics. This is my own personal experience. Take it...

I am a regular customer of Stuff a Bagel Bethpage. I often pick up dozens of bagels from my office staff and buy breakfast for my wife and I a few times a month. Today I went in by myself to get my usual sausage, egg and cheese on an everything bagel which cost around $8. When attempting to pay with a debit card, I was told there was a $10 minimum With no cash on me, they just wouldn’t take my order. I Understand profit margins are probably tight so I can understand a minimum for credit cards, but didn’t think a debit card would be an issue. They would rather not serve a regular customer that spends hundreds of dollars there over one dollar fee on a debit card. Due to their refusal of service, I was forced to go to Orlando deli across the street and my bagel with sausage, egg, and cheese was excellent. Someone should inform the owner that once you change a customer’s buying habits, it’s very difficult to win them back. I hope the one-dollar fee was worth losing a...

I wish I could select zero stars and be able to post a review. I am a local Bethpage resident and have been a regular customer for many, many years. I will never, ever step foot in there again. I know why businessed put up a sign that there is a minimum total to use a credit card, despite this being against NYS and federal law. Credit card fees are a percentage of the total, so it' not like it costs any more to run a charge for less than $10. It's Father's Day, 7:30am and I am alone on ny way to work. Just wanted a bagel and a Yoo-Hoo. $5.33. The cashier pointed out the $10 minimum sign, so I grabbed another Yoo-Hoo. Now we're at $7 something. I don't need anything else. Asked his boss I'd they could make an exception. A very hard NO! I understand that a bagel store isn't the most customer service oriented industry, but the owner should know they lost a customer over $2 of a credit card sale. I don't see how that is worth it. Thank God I don't run a...