Syosset Seafood — Restaurant in Town of Oyster Bay

LOVEEEEE THIS PLACE!! FRESH FISH and HANDS DOWN THE BEST SUSHI!!! You would never think it based on the small place inside where the sushi is, BUT IT IS SOOOO FRESH AND GOOD!! I never realized also how much food options they actually have! Although I don’t have the pics for everything I purchased I DEF recommend the following~

Tuna salad OH MY LORD, the BEST!!! One day I was ordering seafood salad and the person behind the counter also recommended the tuna as it is made with FRESH TUNA. 10000% You must try!! I will never look at canned tuna the same way again…LOL!!! This fresh tuna salad did NOT smell fishy at all. It is SO FRESH!! Makes you wonder what the heck is in the canned tuna. Anyway DEF RECOMMEND. I keep it in my fridge and have for lunch eating it right out of the container. It’s THAT GOOD.

Octopus salad~ Pulpo I think is the name. Same thing! SOOO GOOD! I also keep in the fridge to snack on.

Calamari Salad 👍🏻

Premade spinach and mushroom- 👍🏻 great for side dish for dinner!

Swordfish~ I grill in on the stovetop!! 👍🏻

Crabmeat stuffed mushroom~ awesome as a dinner app!

The only thing I would LOVEEE to see improved is the NEW ENGLAND CLAM CHOWDER. I LOVEEEE New England clam chowder but this one wasn’t flavorful and it was FULL of potatoes and like no clams. As someone who typically follows an Atkins lifestyle I always make an exception for this soup. Sadly, this one was not worth it~ it resembled more cream of potato soup than anything 👎🏻.

If someone reads this review from Syosset seafood…PLEASEEEEE, PLEASEEEEE come up with a new recipe, more (seasonings) flavor, LESS potatoes and MORE clams. Then it would be my one stop shop! Until then, I sadly...

Friday May 16, 2025 5:30 am PST

Syosset Seaford Market.     Address: 293 Robbins Lane, Syosset, Long Island, New York 11791 T (516).681-3771

G. Gary – Owner & Manager - Syosset Seafood Market Team:

I composed this Google Maps Post to express my sincere gratitude for the truly outstanding service you provided in preparing, sending, and successfully delivering my recent order. This order was particularly special, as it was intended to celebrate my mother's 100th birthday and also to wish her a very happy Mother's Day for 2025.

I continue to be so impressed by the exceptional attention to detail you demonstrated throughout this process. From the moment I placed the order to its final delivery, every aspect was handled with the utmost professionalism and care. Knowing that you took such meticulous steps to ensure everything was perfect for this significant occasion meant the world to me.

Furthermore, I was so touched to hear about the courtesy and kindness you extended directly to my mother. Your thoughtfulness in making her feel special on such a momentous day is something I deeply appreciate and will not soon forget. It speaks volumes about your commitment to not just providing excellent seafood, but also to delivering truly personalized and considerate service.

Thank you once again for your exceptional service. You played a significant role in making my mother's 100th birthday and Mother's Day celebration even more memorable. I will certainly be recommending Syosset Seafood Market to friends and family, and I look forward to being a returning customer in the future.

THANK YOU SO MUCH AGAIN FOR GIVI.NG ME “ 7 SEVEN STAR” CUSTOMER...

A few years ago I called Syosset Seafood on my way home from the city- it was 5:45 pm- I know they close at 6 but asked if they could clean and kill 6 lobsters- the answer I got was “we close at 6 and we won’t wait for you” I said I would make it by 6 and they said no. Shame on them- I refused to shop here ever- in the past 6 months I found myself there again- fish is good and sides are good- so today I ran over after getting home from the airport- I didn’t know what time they closed but walked in at 3:55 to hear- wow you just made it- we close at 4. First off- the display cases were empty- everything was gone- I asked if they had bronzino and was told “No- we are all cleaned up and closing” Shame on me! I’m sorry but I was in my own retail business for years and never turned away a customer- if you close at 4 then you serve customers until 4 and then close your doors and clean up- I will NEVER go back to them- there will never be a third...