Pizza Fenice — Restaurant in Town of Pelham

Tues., 10/4/2022 Pizza Fenice😖 is HORRIBLE pizza, on 5th Ave -- in Pelham, NY. The grumpy owner literally slapped on a load of cold pepperoni tonight and rapidly boxed up 2 slices when I asked for "2 slices with pepperoni." The cost was $10!! The pizza that was already prepared was labeled with extremely ridiculous names like "angry bird" and "pacman", so I had absolutely no idea what kind of pizza they were!🙄 When I got home, I FINISHED COOKING the pepperoni on the 2 slices -- in my oven.🙄 UGH!!😖 They were dry and tasteless -- missing that good NY style pizza taste, which I'd been looking forward to, all day.

DO NOT PATRONZE THIS PLACE!

I miss🥺 Marios Pizza (delicious😋, very close to me🏡, and great service). I've been a resident of Pelham, NY for 20 years -- and from now on, I'll be going to "Marcellos", or to "Pelham Pizza" (both make great pizza😋) ... although they are a much further walk from...

Best pizza on THIS PLANET,

I am personally in love with the Detroit style Veggie, which is a deep dish, cheesy crusted DIAMOND of a pizza! My family and I don’t eat meat, so we grab the Veggie, Bandiera which resembles the Italian flag, Detroit Red, Detroit Grandma, omg don’t get me started, the owner John is simply phenomenal with a million ingredient variations and styles to really bring out the best taste in his specialty Pizza! We get to have Detroit style pizza right here in Westchester! I don’t know what’s in that crust but we need more it’s literally the best cheesy crusted crust my entire family has ever tasted!

Alex is super sweet and awesome, hey V! The entire staff is so authentic and kind, super sweet family vibe!

Pizza Fenice we love to call Pizza Fe NICE! It’s NICE PIZZA, NICE ATMOSPHERE, NICE EVERYTHING! Just all around amazing!...

I've been to countless of the best pizzeria spots in Westchester, NYC, and several places around Italy. This pizza shop is hands down my new favorite. Not only because the owner reminded me of my Zio (Uncle), but all the food has that authentic fresh taste that you typically find from food in Italy.

The chicken rolls are made to order, so the quality and taste are outstanding. Remember, quality takes time. The grandma slice and plain slice were so good, I never expected another slice to possibly be better. Now, the Brooklyn Sicilian Pizza - no other pizzeria is coming close to this pie. My wife and I went inside to grab two slices and we left with a chicken roll and an entire pie to bring home. Fresh, airy in the middle, but crisped to perfection on the outside. The perfect amount of sauce on top with the hint of garlic that keeps you coming...