Madison's Pizza & Catering — Restaurant in Town of Pleasant Valley

Ordered 2 chicken Parmigiana dinners, 2 spaghetti and meatball dinners, Buffalo Chicken wrap and a side of meatballs. While the chicken for the chicken parm was good, they only covered the chicken with the minimum mozzarella cheese and did not cover the pasta. This is the only place that I have ordered from that doesn't cover the whole meal. Sauce for the pasta could have had more seasonings for a better taste. The spaghetti dinners barely had any sauce on them, lucky I ordered a side of meatballs and used the sauce from that container to add to the pasta. Sauce is one of the cheapest things you can make so for $60.00 I would think it would pay for a little more cheese and sauce. Don't get me wrong, I will go back but I will ask for extra cheese and extra sauce next time. Hard to find places with good chicken...

Madison’s has been my family’s "go to" for pizza since they first opened. A great place too, for a dependable good meal out, in a comfortable setting with great friendly service. Jason, Madeline and their amazing staff recently catered my daughters' wedding. They helped to make the day incredible. No surprise that the food was great (it always is), but the way they went above and beyond in every aspect was truly remarkable, helping with planning and making important suggestions beyond the food aspect. During cocktail hour, there was no searching or chasing after wait staff for -- they were always there, and assured that the bride, groom & bridal party had hors d'oeuvres brought to them during pictures so they missed nothing. Dinner was plentiful and delicious. Jay, Madeline, family and staff,...

We eat at Madison's and get take out often. We are never disappointed. The staff is helpful and friendly. The food is very reasonably priced. Their menu offers the usual pizza place fare but what makes Madison' stand out is their food is delicious, fresh and not greasy. When you call for pick up, my order is always ready when I arrive. Never had to wait. The Family Size portions are very generous. The menu says these portions serve 4 but it is more like 6 for most normal appetites. We recently hosted a catered party there which was held in their private room. More than 35 people attended. The room was bright and clean. All guests were comfortably seated including some high chairs. The service was friendly, professional , prompt and accommodating. Nearly all our guests commented about how good...