Casey's — Restaurant in Valparaiso

Update 8 months later: I discovered they let you mobile order breakfast now so I gave that a try, hoping they got their issues sorted out in the last 8 months and my food would actually be ready when I arrived. The system estimated the food would be ready in 15 minutes. When I arrived I was told it would be an additional 15 minutes, so the order took a total of 30 minutes to complete. The delay meant I would be late for work without time to eat before starting, so I would have tried to get a refund and go elsewhere but there are no other fast breakfast options early in the morning. Once I commit to going here I have no other options. If I had 30 minutes to wait for food I'd go to an actual restaurant. The issues in my original review below still stand, and I won't ever ba back again. This is very sad as I really like the burritos.

Original: The kitchen is rarely open in the morning, and when it is, it's unlikely anything but pizza is ready. This store used to be great but this problem has been ongoing for several months now. No longer worth going out of my way to go here. I usually arrive around 0600, sometimes a...

I absolutely love Casey's and their food but I have to harp on one individual in particular at this location on 07/25/2025 at around 3:39p because not only did she literally leave the clearly backed up line of customers on register to go have a conversation ON THE CLOCK with her buddy at the gas pump, she had the nerve to make a nasty face at me when I backed out of my spot to leave as if she was going to get hit when there was PLENTY of room for her to have moved or simply put, not gone to the gas pump to gab with her friends in their Cadillac just because she wanted to and leave the young man inside to finish clearing out the line by himself. Do...

Casey’s is not normally my first choice for a gas station but I work close by and I think this location is good . I read a lot of bad reviews about the staff but I have not had any issues . The pop selection is disappointing but I have won some cash off the scratch off lottery tickets here . The breakfast pizza is on point but the sandwiches and wraps are not that great . Overall it’s not a bad place to get gas and a quick snack . I also think the staff is friendly, there is a guy who is pretty hyper running around in there talking to the staff like a chicken with his head cut off so maybe that’s what the negative...