Fratelli's Pizza Rustica — Restaurant in Wallingford

I used to love Fratellis. But the last 3 times it’s been disgusting. I ordered the steak. Idk if you’ve ever bought steak and it turned brown but if you have the smell is rancid. That’s EXACTLY how my steak tasted. It was gross. My boyfriend’s chicken parm was in a pool of bland flavorless sauce and completely soggy and flabby. It was so bad we asked if they’d remake it. They did not want to. Said that’s just how it is. Eventually they remade the chicken but not my steak… but it was exactly the same second time around. It was foul. We paid … even tho we wanted to walk out. They literally didn’t care that it was nasty and we only took 2 bites of each dish. No discount. No nothing. We were met with complete disregard for their customers. Maybe that explains why every time we’ve gone it’s been empty. Idk how they have any good reviews anymore. I’m not ill and want to puke. I can’t get the taste out of my mouth. I hate complaining but now 3x it’s been horrible I feel I have no choice but to warn people. Do yourself a favor and save your $100. I seriously can’t believe we paid $100 for food that tasted like it came out of a dumpster. I’d rather eat McDonald’s and we all know that’s poison. Go anywhere else. Oh AND the chicken parm came with no pasta. What??? Since when? We asked for a side bc we were confused and they charged us an extra $5 for a side of penne. Like what is happening right now?!? DO NOT WASTE YOUR TIME OR RISK YOUR HEALTH. I’m convinced I’m gonna have food poisoning from the 3 bites I took. I couldn’t place the taste but then it came to me. Rancid steak. ...

First time ordering, I am talking about what I ordered,MB grinder it says meat ball Parmesan 12.95,I asked for muzzy $1.00 more 83 year old Italian I thought Parm ment cheese guess not.It was hands down the worst mb grinder I ever had,plus they did not even put sauce on it,zero taste and I mean zero.What my wife ordered ( 2 things )1 she said had no taste the other was a veal dish,to me the pasta did not have much taste in the veal dish.My son went there with is family and said everything was excellent that's why we ordered from them.I never order a meat ball grinder my favorite is sausage.Every time we try a new place I always order meat balls and muzzy with sauce just to find a good meat ball not an easy task.cost was over $70.00 my wife did the ordering came to a part where they asked for a tip she could not get around it so she gave 10%.P.S. Napoli in Cheshire sells ( to me ) an excellent meat ball.The number 1 my wife ordered was broccoli rabe with beans,she can't have sausage because of the fennel seeds,I thought it was very...

Fratelli’s is hands down one of the best spots in town if you’re craving some authentic Italian comfort food. Whether it’s pizza, pasta, or sandwiches, they deliver every time! Their pizza is absolutely phenomenal – the crust is perfectly crispy, and they don’t skimp on the toppings. Whether you go for a classic like pepperoni or one of their specialty pies, you can’t go wrong.

One of my favorite dishes here is the penne vodka. The sauce is creamy and rich, with just the right amount of flavor. They cook the pasta to perfection, and it’s the kind of dish you’ll crave over and over again.

And don’t even get me started on their grinders – they are the bomb! Packed with fresh ingredients and served on soft, toasted bread, each bite is packed with flavor. Whether you’re in the mood for a classic Italian cold cut or a hot meatball grinder, they know how to nail it.

Great service, delicious food, and generous portions make Fratelli’s a must-visit. If you’re looking for real Italian food that hits the spot every time, Fratelli’s is the...