Another Broken Egg Cafe — Restaurant in West Lafayette

Another Broken Egg Cafe offers a delightful brunch experience that skillfully blends southern-inspired charm with a modern twist. From the moment you walk by, you are welcomed by a cozy outdoor atmosphere that immediately sets the tone for a great meal. The staff is warm and courteous, attentive throughout most of the visit, which adds to the overall inviting vibe of the restaurant.

The menu is where Another Broken Egg really shines. Whether you're in the mood for something sweet or savory, there's something for every palate. Favorites like the Lemon Blueberry Goat Cheese Pancakes and the Crab Cake Benedict are expertly prepared and bursting with flavor. Their omelets are a must-try for anyone craving a classic with a bold kick, and their biscuit beignets are the perfect treat to share. They also provide a range of dietary-friendly options, including gluten-free and vegetarian dishes. Their beverage selection is equally impressive, featuring an array of teas, freshly brewed coffee, and fresh juices that complement their menu beautifully.

The downside to our visit was a long wait when it came time to settle the check. While everything else was timely and smooth, it took longer than expected to get the bill, making us late to our next appointment, which interrupted an otherwise seamless experience. Still, the quality of the food, the friendliness of the staff, and the overall ambiance more than made up for it.

All in all, Another Broken Egg Cafe is a fantastic spot for breakfast or brunch. It's a place worth visiting again—and hopefully next time, the check...

Summary: Food seems a little hit-and-miss; great service.

My first time at Another Broken Egg Cafe. Came here with my husband on a Sunday around mid-morning for brunch. The wait was about 30 minutes long and we were seated at one of the high tables.

I decided to try out one of their seasonal specials (Southern Benedict with potatoes) as they were going to be taking this off the menu shortly. My husband got the Chilaquiles.

I can't recommend the Southern Benedict. The biscuit was dry and really bland, one poached egg was done well but the other was overcooked. The sausage was really good but there was way too much ham (that too very salty!) to really appreciate the flavours of the dish. The side of potatoes was pretty average, couldn't really taste any seasoning. Overall a pretty disappointing dish. We did inform our waitress about the salty ham and she took our feedback very well.

The chilaquiles on the other hand was definitely better. Well garnished. I thought it was a little meat-heavy but some people may really enjoy this.

Coffee: Not the greatest. And was lukewarm when served.

Because it was my first time we got treated with their classic sugar dusted beignets which were an absolute delight!

Would I go back? Yes, to try out their other dishes before settling on a...

It was so hard to choose what to eat when all the menu options looked so good! Our server, Esther was super friendly and did a great job. Everything came out super fast, and she checked on us the perfect amount. We ended up having the biscuits and gravy and the blackberry stuffed French toast. Pros: The sausage gravy was seriously delicious! They know how to make their grits. I don’t usually like grits, but these were good. The potatoes were crispy and delicious THE BUTTER RUM SAUCE. Oh my goshhhh, this takes pancakes and French toast to the next level. Some of the best cold brew I’ve ever had. Cons: The biscuit was over baked and too crispy on the bottom. I think I liked the idea of the blackberry and cream cheese French toast more than I liked it in reality. The filling was a bit overwhelming. The seating is really close together. Fine if you’re just having a casual chat with a friend, but definitely not somewhere I would go if you prefer a more private conversation. Overall, we were really happy with our experience, and we’ll definitely be back to try...