Guerriero Gelato & Cakes — Restaurant in West Orange

Mark & Julie’s makes the best chocolate fudge brownie ice cream I’ve had anywhere! The brownies in the ice cream are so soft and chewy! If I were rating that flavor alone it would be definitely 5 stars! I also had the chocolate chip cookie dough, and you wouldn’t believe how good the chocolate pieces tasted in that flavor! I came here last Friday, and I had ordered the brownie sundae. I requested it to come without the cherry or whip cream. I asked the girl how many scoops of ice cream does that come with? She said it comes with 3 very tiny scoops! I was thinking in my head did she just say 3 very tiny scoops! I picked the flavors chocolate fudge brownie and chocolate chip cookie dough to top my brownie. When she finished making it I looked at it, and she wasn’t kidding! There was literally the 3 tiniest scoops of ice cream I ever saw! They were more like 3 tablespoons of ice cream! I said to her can I please have more ice cream on top of the brownie, and I’ll pay whatever it was to have that. She said sure. After she put the additional ice cream she was asking the other girl how much is it for the additional ice cream, and the other girl didn’t know. Then she asked the owner who said well she didn’t get the whip cream or the cherry so keep it the regular price. The brownie sundae was DELICIOUS! Not only was the homemade ice cream so good, but the brownie was fresh, chocolaty, and chewy! I highly recommend ordering it! The prices here were very cheap for the quality of ice cream served. Thats maybe why it only comes with 3 very tiny scoops! I would rather pay a higher price, and have more of their delicious ice cream on top of the brownie sundae. I’ll definitely be coming here every time I’m in the area, and I highly recommend going to Mark & Julie’s ice cream shop in...

If yiu are an icecream lover, this one is for you! We found a Gem. Haha! This is my 1st time trying gelato and icecream here. Honestly I fell in love with those desserts immediately. I was awestruck with the ambience. Its purplish and soo icecream tempting. Hygiene was maintained at every counter. They have larger menu section. I tired pistachio gelato with chocolate waffle and my friend took almond icecream with walnuts as toppings on normal waffle. Pistachio is amazing. Its creamy, rich, perfect sweetness and beautifully served by young ladies. Its the best pistachio gelato I have ever tasted ❤️ with that chocolate waffle its a great combination felt like dubai pistachio icecream. Even Almond flavour tasted Good with that walnuts as toppings its absolutely a flavourful blast for nuts lovers. 🍧🍨 Super clean counters and staff wore gloves. There were many photo corners which are soo funky and attractive to take some photos. We would Definitely come back and try some more flavours. Price is reasonable and found parking quickly just after crossing 2 stores of Right side next to it. I would definitely recommend this Place for kids and any...

As an avid home cook who loves to explore and experiment with new ice cream flavors, I can confidently say that this is the best ice cream I've ever had. I recently visited and tried the Cookie Monster flavor, and it was an absolute delight! The combination of a rich, creamy texture and the perfect balance of sweetness left me craving more with every bite.

The experience was made even more enjoyable by the outstanding service. Andrew, the worker who assisted me, was both friendly (I swear his smile never left his face) and incredibly knowledgeable about the different flavors. He took the time to explain each one in detail and recommended his favorite, the Cookie Monster flavor. Beyond the ice cream, Andrew and I discovered our shared love for running, leading to a pleasant conversation I was sad to step away from. Amazing young bloke.

I can't wait to bring my entire family back here. With such delectable ice cream and exceptional service, it's sure to become a...