Gionino's Pizzeria of Westerville — Restaurant in Westerville

I was told about this pizza place being one of the best in Columbus Ohio by my brother-in-law and several posts I've seen online. Me and my wife decided to give it a try while in Columbus. We arrived at the location and we ordered a plain cheese pie and we also ordered JoJo fries. I am a big fan of Jojo fries I was so shocked they had it at this location. The guy taking our order was very helpful and explained everything as this was our first time at this location. We waited about 15 minutes which was the standard time. Our pizza and fries came out nice and hot. We ate the pizza and the pizza was very good. The JoJo fries were amazing well seasoned. We ordered the 25 count of JoJo fries which lasted a couple of days. I can say that the pizza sauce was a little sweet but not overwhelming. The cheese on the pie was the perfect amount. Overall the food was great. I highly recommend this...

It was hard for me to give this review because I had a good experience with their catering from one of the franchises. Ordering the pizza was very simple and streamlined. I was quoted 30 minutes but it was ready before that. The building is tiny, essentially a walk-in drive-through, with just a counter and beverage fridge. The employees were nice. The pizza was probably in the running for one of the worst pizzas I have had. I ordered a thin-crust cheese and pepperoni, and a regular-crust BBQ pizza. The thin crust was better, but the BBQ was borderline inedible. Both pizzas were soaked in grease, so bad that when I tried to take slices they just broke apart into soggy chunks. You could probably wring them out for grease for more pizzas. Afterward, I felt like I needed to spray dish soap in my mouth to get the greasy feeling out. I was unable to finish and threw a majority of...

I had a bogo free 16 inch 1 topping valpak coupon and decided to check this place out.

We ordered one with pepperoni and one cheese alone. The lady gave me my "cash" total and I inquired if there took credit, she said they did- BUT they charge an up charge of 3%. SO GLAD she told me the cash price, I had time to swing by the ATM and get the $17.95 cash to pay for the pizza, as she indicated my order would take 20-25 minutes.

The pizza was tasty. It travels well and they had a generous amount of toppings. I got the regular crust and it reminded me of 1980's pan pizza from Pizza Hut. Next time I would get the thin crust, as I don't like the family throwing out the crust at the end.

I think the coupon would be the best way to go if you wish to try them. I myself would probably stick with a single topping but that is just my...