Donut Monster — Restaurant in Whitefish Bay

I was given this as a recommendation via Google and I can say the ham,egg, and cheese English muffin was fantastic and $8 a sandwich. This business opens at 8 and I was there at 9 and I was unable to try the peanut butter/jelly donut which I truly wanted to try but it was literally sold out, I will attempt to be there at 7:45a and see if this will get me one of those donuts. It is small, but I loved the idea of pagers that allow you to wait outside for your food. Coming from Mequon I was kinda upset that at 9 things were sold out but no biggie, I grabbed up a maple bacon donut and that was ok. So for my review: Greattt English muffins, expensive, small but great area to just wait outside or ride bike or moto. I would definitely stop in for an English muffin if I am in the area during the temporary business hours of Thurs,Fri,Sat,Sun 8-2, AND the jury is out until tomorrow on the peanut butter/jelly donut. Good luck.

UPDATE: I was able to get a PB&J donut this morning and it taste like a raspberry topping with a creme filling that taste like the Halloween peanut butter candy in the orange and black wrappers not to strong though which in my opinion was good. I also tried a Japanese nitro which was great but I do recommend cups with smaller mouth openings or straw openings. OF COURSE I had another ham,egg and cheese sandwich🙂. Overall good sandwiches, great coffee, and PB&J donut. Only gut wrenching issue is price and I personally can overlook that if I am in the neighborhood. I recommend you stop in and...

Skip the donuts?

Arrived 10mins after opening on a Saturday morning. Two lines (cars & standing folks) - was 10th in the standing line. Orders taken equitably between the two. Took about 35mins total.

Ordered 6 donuts (chocolate buttercream filled, buttermilk OF with sprinkles, mixed berry cheesecake, salted chocolate, lemon curd OF, maple bacon) and the nitro cold brew special (honey & oat milk)

Really wanted to love these. The maple bacon and coffee were great, would order again (once the wait subsides). The rest of the donuts were not good. The old fashioned style are skinny, which looks different (artisanal!) but they were dense and dry-ish, flavors ranged from meh to inedible. The salted chocolate was inedible - bizarre not-chocolate-but-i-don't-know-what taste. My husband, sons and I ended up not finishing them (unheard of).

The staff were efficient and kind, the storefront and logo are super appealing and local ingredients are what we'd all prefer.... but the donuts are disappointing. Seems like everyone is all about the sandwiches - will try those sometime.

Go to Grebe's on Lincoln. Crueller, honeymooner,...

My first and last time coming here. The customer service was absolutely atrocious.

The cashier was simply rude to say the least. If you don't want to service minority customers, then find a different job. She had that uncomfortable look of, just hurry up, stop looking at the donuts, just get out.

First, she didn't speak AT ALL, only to state the total. After I HANDED her the money, I extend my hand so she can give me the change in the same manner. Does she? No. What does she decide to do? Place the five dollar bill and quarter on the counter next to the box and stare at me.

As if to say, get it yourself.

The next caucasian patron enters and look at that. She CAN speak. She CAN hand someone their box and change. WOW! Not shocked.

As for the donuts we tried the cinnamon toast donut, lemon poppyseed donut, chocolate stuffed with vanilla buttercream and s'mores fritter.

The dough they're using is light and fluffy and has a great texture; However, due to the poor customer service it's definitely not worth...