Play It Again Sports of Appleton — Attraction in Appleton

Store laid out well, many different offerings available for all kinds of equipment. Nice indoor batting cages. The negative is the prices. These are a bit higher in comparison to other locations, but the upsetting complaint was the offering of a sale for 2 days. Baseball bags, batting gloves, glasses, and a number of other items were advertised as 50% off in a generic flyer over this equipment. When you got to the cash register it was a different story; only 20% off of the items on one side of the store. This could have simply been rectified by placing 20% off over that equipment and 50% over the areas where the sale would be and then a large sign in the middle pointing out what was what. They refused to honor the 50% price at register even when it was within eyeshot. Good deals on used equipment but I cannot in good conscience support this...

Large, well equipped store with friendly staff. We went to our locally owned and operated store seeking bindings for a snowboard. Scored what appeared to be never or nearly never used Flow Alpha bindings for $50. We were first interested in base plates used to mount the bindings to the board. A staff member, despite being busy, took the time to look in their parts bin, and then get the manager involved. Finding none, we took time to look around and a third, knowledgeable staff person helped us out.

This store has a lot of equipment, new and used, including batting cages. They also have a pretty generous return policy for new and used equipment AND they rent out some equipment.

Not all stores are the same but this Appleton store should be...

Buy and sell used sports equipment! This is one of several locations.

Here you will find a store where you can buy and sell used sports equipment. They also stock new products as well. The selection is pretty good and the prices are very affordable compared to new. This location is large, probably twice the size of the Green Bay location. The staff is also very friendly and they have no problem letting you browse the store. As with any second hand shop, you will need to stop in frequently to review the selection. They may not always have what you want.

I would recommend stopping in here before ordering online or going to a...