Jeremiah's Italian Ice — Local services in Fruit Cove

Slightly disappointed. Purchased 2 quarts (jelati and an ice cream) and 2 personal sized jelati. The quart of jelati had 80% Italian ice (and yes there is a price difference! quart ice cream -$8.99, Italian ice- $7.99 but Jelati is the same price as the ice cream at $8.99 so, I expect there to be approx half ice cream or more.) You’d think an easy solution would be to just get a quart of ice cream and a quart of Italian ice then you’d have 50/50… but the quart of ice cream wasn’t even full and there was a “tunnel” in the middle. Both personal sized jelati‘s weren’t as full as they are when purchasing from the orange park location. I felt a bit gypped. All that said, I understand this location just opened. I also understand that most of the employees are young and may not yet fully appreciate “getting your money’s worth”. I’ll give them a few more chances to do better in the future and I’ll update my review accordingly. When it all comes down to it, everything is so expensive. My coffee creamer nearly doubled in price from last year, but at least I’m confident I’m getting...

I love Jeremiah’s it has the best tasting Italian ice cream I’ve ever tasted. The people that waited on me were fast and friendly. The new Middleburg location is going to be a great opportunity for all to try this place if you haven’t. Well worth it . I bought the new pumpkin pie jelati cake. Oh my was it so good it tasted just like eating pumpkin pie the crispy things they add to it really give it the taste of crust in the pie. I was really pleased with my order. It’s only seasonal though so don’t miss out on this. I’ll be having it for my families Thanksgiving if it’s...

A must stop on the way home. Mix it up don't forget to try the different sprinkles and the chocolate soft serve.... double check the menu as it changes weekly, see something new and what to try before you buy ask for a sample...and give it a shot I kinda love the...