Who's On First? — Local services in Huntington

Simple and plain down home old school card shop! The owner was very informative while also not being your typical jerky boy of a card shop owner. You could tell he was raised right and had couth. Now if there was 10 Stars I would rated 10 Stars. He worked with us he was not firm on prices enjoyed the haggle ( which is a rare thing)The typical kid in the shop was not your typical kid.vHs name is Kyle and that kid started working at the shop a year and a half prior to the sports card boom. A very knowledgeable college kid who had the right answer for everything which is"the boss man got the price"even though you could tell he had the answer yet he acted as a respectful and punctual teenager should. I will definitely be back and have already passed the word around....

This place is very shady. Be careful in your dealing with this place. The guy will try to sell you cards based on eBay comps that includes shipping for the highest prices. For in person sales I may add. However, when you try to sell him any card he does not look at comps correctly, and tries to use the cheapest comps no matter when they are from. Any serious card collector please be aware as this is not how anyone should conduct business. And as he told me, “thanks for telling me what card to buy cheaper since its on the rise, even though I won’t buy yours.“ Well, thank you for being the worst card shop in the Tri-State area, as well as lying to your customers faces. I will take my business elsewhere to places like Baseball...

I’ve been going to who’s on first for yrs. Gary and Buck are great people treat people really good. Very knowledgeable and helpful.Lots of different kind of different kind of cards to pick from. They have baseball football basketball some reds Memorabilia Rose, Griffey and others. And if you wanna find something, they’ll help you find it. I got a lot of nice pools...