All-Stars Collectibles — Local services in Middletown Township

Interaction?? Abruptly short and quite unpleasant. So this was last year sometime, came across a few baseball cards and mind you, I know nothing about baseball cards, but I recognized the one name Mike Schmidt. If I spelled that right..any ways I brought them in along with the others prob like 30-40 total and from the moment I stepped in I felt like the elephant in the room. Long story short, when I asked if any of them were worth anything, the reply was " if they were I'd probably have them already" with out even looking at them. Idk if it was my flat rim snapback turns to the side or the aviators but def felt judged for lack of other words. Anyways I haven't been back in the store since nor would I care to. But that's just me. It may be different for u. Im not saying don't go there, cuz that be rude, but if u do hope your experience is better than mine...

I came here a handful of times as a kid and bought two vintage cards, but now that I've returned to the hobby as an adult, this is where I come for the new stuff too. I started about 6 months or so ago and Warren and Tracy helped be choose products that I'd like the best. They also taught me a lot about different aspects of the hobby. I didn't even know what a parallel was when I walked in there 6 months ago! Any time I need binders or pages or one touch holders, I come here and usually leave with a box or pack of the latest Topps product. I can't say enough great things about Warren, Tracy, and their store. Even though most of the reviews here are positive, I've read some of the negative ones and I have to say, those people are the problem, not the store...

Some good staff, one very incompetent staff member; this one man in particular had absolutely no clue what I was looking for when I told him the item was a "Magic: The Gathering card". Everyone else seems very helpful.

The store is small and cramped in some ways, however many shops like this with collectables are. They have everything from sports memotobillia to magic cards, all the way to standalone M:TG products and D&D 5th edition products.

Not as well priced inventory as online distributors, however this is a local brick and mortar game store and that is to be expected; Do the community a favor and spend a little extra (when you can of course) to support one of the (very) few businesses that do in fact support some local...