Mary's Mountain Cookies — Local services in Peoria

Sweet Mountain of Deliciousness: 5 Stars for Mary's Mountain Cookies! Where do I even begin? Mary's Mountain Cookies isn't just a bakery, it's a wonderland for cookie lovers! Their selection is absolutely phenomenal, with something to tantalize every taste bud. From classic Chocolate Chip to unique creations like Orange Doodle and S'mores, there's a flavor adventure waiting around every corner.

But it's not just the variety that impressed me. The quality of the cookies is top-notch. Every bite is a symphony of fresh ingredients, perfectly balanced flavors, and that melt-in-your-mouth texture that dreams are made of. I couldn't stop myself from going back for seconds (and maybe thirds...).

Plus, the staff at Mary's Mountain Cookies are delightful. They're friendly, knowledgeable, and genuinely passionate about their product. They helped me navigate the vast selection and even offered a few samples, which only solidified my love for their cookies!

Whether you're a die-hard cookie enthusiast or just looking for a sweet treat, Mary's Mountain Cookies is a must-visit. Their incredible selection, exceptional quality, and friendly service make them truly...

The cookie I got here was the driest, thinnest, stalest tasting excuse of a cookie I’ve ever paid for. This poor quality of a cookie was around $5. I wouldn’t even give it a value of over $1.29! It was a peanut butter cookie dipped half in dark chocolate. I hardly noticed the taste of peanut butter. It tasted like stale crackers hidden in the back of my great aunt Shirley’s pantry. 🍪 I don’t get it. As I’m leaving this review, it has 4.7 stars. With only 80 reviews though. . . Theres definitely people who have had similar experiences to mine who simply have not LEFT a review! Probably for the same reason! It’s EMBARRASSING to have to say I had a disgusting experience with a FRESH BAKED COOKIE! Worth acknowledging too is how short and disrespectful the woman was who helped me. There was a strong feeling of “I don’t like you. & you are not important as a customer....

I just don't understand the rave reviews. NO BUTTER! You cannot make a good tasting cookie without butter. But honestly the blueberry cheesecake, which tastes nothing like cheesecake, tastes like a blueberry muffin and was good. But I came in for cookies and not muffins. After nearly $30 and a week later, the box is still sitting with half eaten cookies. I kept trying them on different days thinking it was me but no, they don't taste like anything. The peanut butter didn't even taste like peanut butter. When I went to the website to look at the ingredients, it all made sense. The basic cookie recipe, the base of all of their cookies, are made with oil. I've made a lot of cookies in my life and while they don't look all decorated and nice, they taste amazing! I...