New Blackwell Jewelers — Local services in Rockaway

I have been to this business a few times to sell some gold and silver jewelry. Very reasonable prices were offered to me. I can say this with 100% honesty because my first 2 times i went there i left with the offer he gave me and went elsewhere (wanted to make sure i wasn't being ripped off). Was also going place to place because i wanted the most money which is basically kinda the whole point when selling your valuables lol.(mostly went to places in Morristown NJ) Offers i received at a few of them were decent if i hadn't known any better and didn't shop around. This one particular shop though (kinda near where the movie theater is)made me feel so creeped out as soon as i walked in. Very uncomfortable feeling to say the least. I felt like they saw me as a junkie and desperate, which proved me right when they pretended to closely examine every peice i had and only had negative comments on each one. Thinking i would take their word and be happy with whatever they offered me i guess. I feel if i woulda said kneel down and kiss my shoes and I'll take your offer, both of them would have in a heartbeat lol. I finished with a few choice words i can't repeat here. Before i walked out i did manage to say how much of a low life do you have to be to try and screw someone out of $1650!!! YES $1650!!! So common sense had me back in Dover. Blackwell Jewelers offered me $1930 when i first went there. But i told him my experience at the one disgusting place, and how the other places treated me well, but were still a couple hundred off. Im drawing a blank on his name (he's the owner) but considering i came back to his shop for being trustworthy, he was generous and rounded the offer up to $1950. I now go to him and only him when i have jewelry i need to sell, random sports memorabilia that was signed and other random things. His honesty is what makes me keep going back. There have been things he could've taken from me but said i would get more money if i took it to such and such place. Long post sorry. But all in all i highly...

I was nervous about trusting a jeweler with gold I had and wanted to have remade. After doing some research online, I called and spoke with Fabio. After just a few minutes, I was extremely comfortable and looking forward to doing business with him. Fabio and I designed a few original bracelets…he was very open to couple my ideas with his expertise. I did not know what to expect, but to say my expectations were exceeded is putting it extremely mildly. The final designs and workmanship were exquisite! These three bracelets were the beginning. Fabio has designed rings, necklaces, and the most exciting piece will be delivered as a “secret” Christmas gift. I have such confidence and trust in his creative abilities, that I asked him to design a bracelet for me, which he will give to me wrapped, and I will open and see for the first time on Christmas morning. My excitement and expectations are through the roof! I can’t wait! I’m so grateful to find a businessman that is kind, a very nice and genuine person, and very fair in his dealings with his customers.

If you’re looking for an honest expert in jewelry, give him a call. You will be very glad you did!

I just received my Christmas present mentioned above and had to return to post photos! As they have done since the first time I used them, the final product was so far beyond what I could have ever imagined. Not only is this an excellent standalone piece, but in their tasteful way and ability to connect with your sense of style, it compliments the other pieces they made me. I’ve attached photos but please know that the photos do this piece no justice! Fabio and team, thank you for the supreme craftsmanship and heart that you put into every piece of jewelry you produce. You have once again exceeded my expectations on every level. From the bottom of my heart, Thank You! Have a very blessed Christmas and...

We have been customers of Blackwell jewelers for many years when they were in dover and now since they moved to rockaway. We recently went to them after not coming due to our family dealing with our mom having health issues. Now she’s on the mend and finally was excited to dress up put her jewelry on and go to a family wedding. They went above and beyond to accommodate our family when we were simply getting new batteries for watches and running around to do last minute preparations for the wedding. The wonderful staff at Blackwell was like oh we will fix the watches up and we will bring them to your local location so you don’t miss your appointment and you can have your watches for the wedding. The absolute best customer service ever so accommodating and so pleasant. They made my mom and our families gathering wonderful from great kindness compassion and...