Madalyn's Fine Jewelry — Local services in Saint Augustine

Madalyn’s Fine Jewelry is an outstanding jewelry store with a beautiful selection of jewelry and reasonable prices! I have shopped at a number of “fine” jewelry stores over the years and Madalyn’s is, in my opinion, the best jewelry store I’ve ever had the pleasure of dealing with. I was looking for a custom jeweler to remake my wedding rings and spent a lot of time researching independent jewelry stores in the area. After reading many reviews, I decided to go to Madalyn’s. It was definitely the right decision! I met with Jamie Dodge who is truly an amazing jeweler/artist. She was very patient and understood what I was looking for. Jamie created a truly outstanding, unique custom setting that more than met my expectations. I absolutely love my new rings – they are stunning!

I also had the pleasure to meet Corinne on another visit to Madalyn’s; she, too, was very friendly and knowledgeable. I am so happy to now have a trusted, talented jeweler and a store that I can go to for all my future jewelry purchases/needs. Thank you, Jamie...

This place was awful. The lady was just flat out rude. I think her name was Janie. She made me feel like my business was not important. She made me feel like I simply did not matter. It is a very tiny showroom and they didn’t have a decent selection of diamond engagement rings anyway. (outdated jewelry, in my opinion.) I was on a shopping mission for an engagement ring by myself because my future fiancé travels and has left this task to me. Maybe because of the way that I was dressed or the fact that I was alone. Little did she know that our ring budget would have purchased just about anything I wanted in her store had she been a bit more interested in actually selling diamonds and less inclined to judge me. This place is not worth your time if you’re choosing one of the most important pieces of jewelry in...

Such a great experience! I went to Madalyn's today to get one of my old necklaces my boyfriend got me repaired. I didn't know what gold it was and they were able to find a match for the gold and the clasp I originally had. I also didn't ask them but it looks like the cleaned up the chain a little bit on my necklace and it looks perfect. On top of their great work they said it was on the house as a gesture for the holidays. Really kind workers and they have an adorable puppy. I'm not looking into getting engaged now, but if I was, I would look here. Just from glancing I saw rings that were so close to some in my dreams. This is a really wonderful and welcoming local jewelry store and sure made my day to go there. Even if you just love looking and beautiful jewelry, I would treat yourself to a...