Mr Brooks Stonegrill & Bar — Restaurant in Melbourne

Tried this place for the first time and had high hopes considering the reviews but the actual experience was a significant let down. We ordered Scallops and Crochets for entre. Scallops were bland, absolutely no seasoning and bit under cooked. Crochets we're fine but nothing outstanding. For mains we got a Tenderloin steak on stone grill with Peppercorn and Chimichurri sauce. Steak was fine. Our other option, Lamb Shank wasn't available so ended up getting Seafood pasta which wasn't bad. Both the sauces that we got with the Steak were terrible. Peppercorn sauce tasted putrid. Warning: Do not order that sauce. Service was a bit off (but based on other reviews this seems consistent). First we were given cutlery that was dirty. They swapped it when we pointed it out but there was no apology conveyed. Waitress kept making awkward jokes which we could live without. Was only given steak knives and no cutlery for Entree. So having tender scallops with a big as Steak knife was quite an experience. Worst of all, they brought out entrees and mains almost at the same time which meant there was no room on our table and steak kept cooking and stone grill got cold by the time we got to it. If this was a pub, then a different story but if you are going to charge over $50 for your steak, your service needs to be on point. The Owner/Manager behind the counter didn't seem interested in feedback. One star is for the waitress who had just started working there and was very warm, friendly and caring. The only food item we enjoyed were the roast potatoes that came with the Steak (although we weren't given an option to chose either Fries or Greens). Nice and Crisp and...

If you’re looking for a place that has good food, good vibes and great service. Then Mr, Brooks is the one. Birthday party? No worries!! They got your back! Just drop the cake at the bar and they’ll take care of it. Having an open kitchen where you can see what the chef is cooking for you and they’re very friendly who will smile to you or say thank you when you’re leaving (if they’re not running up and down on a busy night =)))) ). The bar is great. Mr. Brooks will get you drunk if you’re wish to with their drink menu. They have the whole list of cocktails, mocktails, wines and other non- alcoholic drinks. Now, let’s digninto the food. Ugrhh. It’s so yummy. You can’t move onto main without trying Kilpatrik oysters, buffalo wings or the delicious croquettes. Chilli mussel is spot on for those who loves 🔥 which will be served with bread to dip in. Their signature for main is the stone grill served with roasted chat potato on side and a choice of sauce (let me know which one is your fav). Beside that, pasta is a bomb as well. They have lobster pasta and seafood pasta…yummmmmmmmm. So many other things to try like pork ribs, lamb schank, burgers etc (you tell me!! :D ) Dessert is good as well....

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

I had the absolute pleasure of dining at Mr. Brooks the other night with my past clients as we reminisced about their incredible wedding—and wow, what an experience! From the moment we walked in, the atmosphere was buzzing. The place was jam-packed (which says a lot), yet the service was still exceptional—attentive, warm, and flawless.

Now, let’s talk about the food—because it was remarkable. Every dish was a masterpiece, with flavours that were perfectly balanced and presentation that was simply stunning. You can tell there’s a true passion for quality here. Generous servings, fair pricing, and every bite an experience.

The owner? Absolutely fantastic—genuinely welcoming and invested in ensuring everyone has a great time. You can feel the love poured into this place. It’s truly a hidden gem that deserves to be on everyone’s must-visit list.

Whether you're after an unforgettable meal, a place to celebrate, or simply somewhere to indulge in phenomenal food, Mr. Brooks delivers on all fronts. I’ll absolutely be back—again and again. Highly, highly,...