Cafe Mystique
Cafe Mystique things to do, attractions, restaurants, events info and trip planning
Plan your stay
Posts
Wish I could leave zero stars. Paid with a $100 bill that had a tear in it and they wouldn't accept it. Had a busboy come over and shout at us when we asked the hostess to call the manager and ask if they'd take the bill. He said "why you come in here with a bill like that?" They were acting like I was trying to get over on them somehow. I'm literally with the hostess now, walking up and down Castro because each bank the hostess checks (with us following her) is closed. Just take the bill?? With her now, still!! Here's a picture of the bill attached. As you can see, it has a tear, but is not torn in half. Edit: just left finally. The hostess made change with our $100 bill at a store a block and a half away. When we all finally walked together back to the restaurant, and paid, she refused to let me tip my server. After being treated so poorly by everyone but my server, I wanted to tip her. Hostess physically grabbed my arm and took the money I tried to tip with out of my hand. She said they don’t want my tip. I demanded that the server be allowed to take my tip. Hostess said fine, and motioned for me to give it to her. I said no it’s for the server. Eventually she let I me give it to my server. Will never come back to this place. So, for no reason, the hostess wouldn’t accept a $100 bill with a tear, took it upon herself to make change with my bill at a different establishment, and then it was pulling teeth to tip my server!! Btw, had a kale Caesar salad with chicken. It was subpar. Glad the food was meh because the service is trash and I wouldn't come back even if the food was good.
A L J
10
More than I expected! Popped in here last night over the holiday weekend after venturing out into The Castro. The ambiance was warm and inviting inside. The number of guests eating outside was a good indicator this was a place worth visiting. My server was friendly and informative. I appreciated his light conversation on a busy night. The owner was gracious and kept a good eye on the dining room as well as the cooks line. He was hands-on so I knew the place would hum along as it did. I ordered the green beans as a starter. Good texture and flavor. I love my green veggies after all. The lemon pasta sounded safe and it was surprisingly delicious and delivered more flavor than I expected. So glad I went this route. The white burgundy by the glass was a nice touch and change from oaky Chardonnay’s found on the West Coast. (How may I thank you enough?) My ice cream with caramel sauce and almonds wrapped up the meal and made my happy as a clam. I’ll be back!
R “Purple Goat Eater” K
20
SO. GOOD. Hybrid Mediterranean, Italian, and other cuisines. If you're looking for something new, interesting, and most of all, TASTY, come eat here! We had amazing Asian inspired green beans (get them!), amazingly creative and delicious salmon over quinoa with a balanced, nuanced, and complex flavor profile, topped with a peach sauce that had the perfect pinch of sweet (get that too!). One of us got a burger with the garlic fries, and let me tell you, the fries were BOMB. They had just the right amount of garlic, and the fries themselves were moist but not greasy, crisp (but not too crunchy) on the outside, and soft but not mushy on the inside. Who knew French fries could be perfected??? The service and the atmosphere were both great, and the only negative was the price. We're all college students, so definitely can't eat here every night, but it was so SO worth it.
Eve Matson
10
UPDATE JAN 2024 15yrs later and Cafe Mystique is still standing @ "The Stro," San Francisco. They got to be doing something good to be around that long. I get it!! Owners still do an amaizing job as ever with their quality customer service and trainning. The waiter/servers/staff are what Castro needs.... well grommed, well trained and pretty spot on at their work.. A holiday break in SF is always worth it when I have Cafe Mystique to rely on no doubt!!! Always and 4Ever a 5Star. WHEN IN THE CASTRO, WHERE ELSE BUT CAFE MYSTIQUE".. hehehe....they know I love them since I walked into their restaurant on the first day they opened and 13+ yrs later iam still going there. That's my go to place when in San Francisco. U will never know until u try it out... its definitely always a 5star in my book... ❤
Jay Jamal
10
The Castro has long been known for bad overpriced restaurants in the foodie paradiso of SF. Mystique is an exception. They offer some kind of Mediterranean fusion, many Italian dishes NOT prepared in an Italian form. There serve four or five risottos: Chicken, Shrimp, Lemon, lamb and beef (?) risotto, each seasoned mild, medium or spicy. I had the chicken mild, very spicy for me. But it was very good. The rice was perfect, and not a soupyl, which I hate. Nice quiet atmosphere inside or also. they have seating n the street.
MICHAEL LEE
00
UPDATE JAN 2024 15yrs later and Cafe Mystique is still standing @ "The Stro," San Francisco. They got to be doing something good to be around that long. I get it!! Owners still do an amaizing job as ever with their quality customer service and trainning. The waiter/servers/staff are what Castro needs.... well grommed, well trained and pretty spot on at their work.. A holiday break in SF is always worth it when I have Cafe Mystique to rely on no doubt!!! Always and 4Ever a 5Star. WHEN IN THE CASTRO, WHERE ELSE BUT CAFE MYSTIQUE".. hehehe....they know I love them since I walked into their restaurant on the first day they opened and 13+ yrs later iam still going there. That's my go to place when in San Francisco. U will never know until u try it out... its definitely always a 5star in my book... ❤
Jay Jamal
10
Nearby Attractions Of Cafe Mystique
Dolores Park
Wela Thai Massage and Spa
The Castro Theatre
Corona Heights Park
Duboce Park
Cliff's Variety
Mission San Francisco de Asis
Helen Diller Playground
Randall Museum
GLBT Historical Society Museum

Dolores Park
4.7
(6.4K)
Click for details

Wela Thai Massage and Spa
5.0
(1K)
Click for details

The Castro Theatre
4.7
(1.2K)
Click for details

Corona Heights Park
4.8
(797)
Click for details
Nearby Restaurants Of Cafe Mystique
Tartine Bakery
Kitchen Story
Orphan Andy's Restaurant
Starbelly
U:Dessert Story
Anchor Oyster Bar
Pizzeria Delfina - Mission
The Detour
Fable
Le Marais Bakery

Tartine Bakery
4.5
(2.6K)
Click for details

Kitchen Story
4.4
(1.2K)
Click for details

Orphan Andy's Restaurant
4.5
(1.1K)
Click for details

Starbelly
4.4
(991)
$$
Click for details
Basic Info
Address
464 Castro St, San Francisco, CA 94114
Map
Phone
(415) 865-9963
Call
Reviews
Overview
4.4
(394 reviews)
Ratings & Description
Description
Cozy eatery specializing in Moroccan dishes as well as American meals & happy hours.
attractions: Dolores Park, Wela Thai Massage and Spa, The Castro Theatre, Corona Heights Park, Duboce Park, Cliff's Variety, Mission San Francisco de Asis, Helen Diller Playground, Randall Museum, GLBT Historical Society Museum, restaurants: Tartine Bakery, Kitchen Story, Orphan Andy's Restaurant, Starbelly, U:Dessert Story, Anchor Oyster Bar, Pizzeria Delfina - Mission, The Detour, Fable, Le Marais Bakery
The Hit List

- Please manually select your location for better experience