This joint may be nostalgic for some in the area. I was actually recommended the pizza by a neighbor who described it with such enthusiasm. I have always believed there's no such thing as bad pizza. That all changed after trying Pepi's Pizza. We were SO hungry so we ordered pizza and garlic bread. Their pizza is reminiscent of back of the freezer flavored crust and toppings that lack any of the expected flavor. Feta tasted like it had been left open in the fridge to evaporate the flavors. It tasted like stale milk and the feta oddly lacked salt, like it had been washed away just like the olives. Olives had no salt and no olive flavor. Clearly a trend. Pepperoni was so oddly rubbery tasting and smelling. Texture was not rubber, it was off on every level. My house didn't even smell like pizza; completely unrecognizable. Ceci n'est pas une pizza if you know what I mean. After opening the box the rubbery smell of erasers and tires filled the room even more. I still took 2 bites since I hadn't eaten all day and I was literally desperate to eat the food we bought. First bite I was so confused. Surely, this wasn't pizza. I took another bite, that's when I was hit with the same unrecognizable flavor and texture. That's when we realized that Pepi's took our money proudly and sent the most sad excuse for food I've ever experienced in my life. We got scammed at the dinner table. The only edible item was the cheesy garlic bread. The bread was the freshest part of the meal. It lacked enough garlic spread to make an impact so it read more as cheese bread. I'm just happy that we had at least one thing to eat that night. The pizza went straight down the chute because I couldn't handle that pungent rubbery smell and dumpster dive taste. This may sound harsh but this is an honest review. Pepi's Shitza is what it should be called.