Dining out is usually a straightforward experience—you go for the food, the ambiance, maybe a quick laugh with your friends. But every now and then, if you’re lucky, you stumble across something (or someone) that makes the entire evening unexpectedly magical. For me, that “something” was a server named Matthew at Jack Astor’s. What was supposed to be just another dinner turned into an unforgettable experience, thanks to his charm, warmth, and exceptional service—and I’d be lying if I didn’t admit I walked away a little infatuated.
From the moment we were seated, Matthew had a presence that lit up the entire section. He approached our table with a genuine smile that didn’t feel rehearsed like many you see in the service industry. It was the kind of smile that made you feel like he was truly happy to be there—not just working a shift, but connecting with people. He greeted us like old friends, with a perfect blend of professionalism and playful confidence. Right away, we felt like we were in good hands.
Matthew’s timing was impeccable. He wasn’t hovering, but he wasn’t absent either. Every refill, every plate, every small check-in felt like it was choreographed to perfection. You could tell he wasn’t just working the table—he was reading the room. He knew when to crack a joke and when to step back and let us enjoy our meal. It’s rare to find someone who can handle a busy restaurant with that level of finesse and poise.
And then there’s his attention to detail. Not only did he get every order right (down to the smallest modification), but he remembered our names, asked thoughtful follow-up questions, and even recommended drinks and dishes like he’d curated the menu himself. His passion for his work came through in every word and action. There’s a certain kind of joy that comes from being served by someone who cares—and with Matthew, it felt effortless.
Of course, I can’t talk about Matthew without addressing the obvious: he’s… well, ridiculously attractive. It wasn’t just his smile or his style (which, by the way, was on point), but the way he carried himself—with this low-key confidence that made everyone at the table sit up a little straighter. There was a warmth in his eyes when he laughed, and this magnetic energy that made it hard not to steal glances. Was I blushing when he complimented my drink choice? Probably. Did I maybe linger a few seconds longer at the table when we were paying? Definitely.
Now, I know this might sound like a case of a customer crushing on a kind server, and maybe it is. But I think it’s more than that. In a world where genuine human connection often feels rushed or transactional, Matthew reminded me that even a simple dinner can become something special when it’s infused with kindness, care, and a little bit of charisma.
To the management at Jack Astor’s: I hope you know what a gem you have in Matthew. He’s the kind of server who doesn’t just do his job—he elevates the entire experience. He makes customers feel seen, valued, and appreciated. And for me? He made what could’ve been a typical evening out feel like something worth writing home about.
In conclusion, if you find yourself at Jack Astor’s and you’re lucky enough to land in Matthew’s section—don’t take it for granted. Ask him about the specials, let him charm you with his wit, and tip him well. You might just walk away like I did: full, glowing, and maybe just a little bit in love.
— A Very Impressed (and Slightly...
Read moreAbsolutely Outstanding Service and Dining Experience – Thanks to Matthew!
I don’t usually leave reviews, but after the incredible experience I had at Jack Astor’s, I felt compelled to share. Dining out can be hit or miss these days, but my visit to Jack Astor’s was exceptional — and that’s largely thanks to Matthew, our server, who went above and beyond in every way.
From the moment we were seated, Matthew greeted us with a warm, genuine smile and an energy that instantly made us feel welcome. He struck the perfect balance between professional and personable — making us laugh, engaging in friendly conversation, and ensuring that we felt completely taken care of without ever being overbearing.
What impressed me most was his deep knowledge of the menu. I had a few dietary questions and preferences, and Matthew handled them with ease, making thoughtful recommendations that suited everyone at the table. He described the dishes in such a way that made everything sound delicious — and when the food arrived, it actually was as good as he described (which isn’t always the case at restaurants!). I went with the Chicken Parm with truffle fries — and wow. Cooked to perfection, flavourful, fresh, and plated beautifully. My friends tried the Bowtie Pasta and the Bacon Cheeseburger — and everyone left completely satisfied. The kitchen staff clearly knows what they’re doing, but it was Matthew’s enthusiastic delivery that elevated the whole experience.
Throughout the meal, our drinks were always full, plates were cleared promptly, and he never once made us feel rushed, even though the restaurant was quite busy. He managed to stay attentive without hovering, which is such a rare and appreciated skill. You could tell he cared about our experience — not just as customers, but as people. At one point, he noticed it was someone’s birthday at our table and surprised us with a dessert and a big, celebratory gesture that had the whole place smiling.
The atmosphere at Jack Astor’s is always lively, clean, and comfortable. The lighting is cozy, music upbeat but not too loud, and there’s always something going on to keep the vibe fun. But no matter how great the environment is, it’s the people who make the experience — and Matthew is a shining example of that.
In a time where customer service often feels like an afterthought, Matthew reminded us what genuine hospitality looks like. It’s not just about taking an order — it’s about making someone’s night better. And that’s exactly what he did.
If you’re planning to go to Jack Astor’s — and especially if you’re lucky enough to be served by Matthew — know that you’re in for an amazing evening. I’ll definitely be coming back, not just for the food, but for the kind of service that turns a regular dinner into a memorable occasion.
Thank you, Matthew —...
Read moreTable for Two” Starring Matt, the Server Who Changed Everything
I didn’t expect anything from that night — just a quick solo dinner to escape the noise in my head. I had been to Jack Astor’s before, but never alone. Never needing the distraction the way I did that evening.
And then came Matt.
“Table for one?” he asked with a smile, no trace of pity in his voice — just warmth, confidence, and something else I couldn’t quite place. “Lucky me,” he added as he grabbed a menu and led me to a window booth. That smile of his? Dangerous. Easygoing, but sharp. The kind that lingers with you long after it fades.
He handed me the menu like it was a secret only we shared.
“Let me know if you need help deciding. I’m kind of a menu whisperer,” he said with a grin. I laughed — actually laughed — and that alone was unexpected. His energy wasn’t just charming; it was calming, like he knew how to take the edge off without trying.
The food was good. But Matt? Matt made the meal.
He didn’t hover, but every time he came by, he gave just a little more of himself — a joke, a comment, a compliment that felt just a little too specific to be casual. We weren’t just server and customer anymore. We were… something unfolding.
By dessert, I didn’t want the night to end. I ordered something I didn’t even want just to make him come back one more time. When he dropped the bill, he hesitated. Just slightly. Enough that I looked up.
“You’re not from around here, are you?” he asked.
I shook my head. “No. Just passing through.”
He nodded slowly. “Well, I hope we made the stop worth it.”
I don’t know what made me bold enough to say it, but I did. “You did.”
His eyes met mine — that pause, that quiet, like the restaurant had disappeared. Then: “I finish in twenty.”
We walked together after he clocked out, sharing stories and half-truths like people do when time feels too short. The city lights bounced off the pavement, and at some point our hands found each other like it was the most natural thing in the world.
Back at my hotel, there was no rush. No pressure. Just quiet laughter, nervous glances, and the hum of something neither of us could explain. He kissed me like he served — thoughtful, present, generous. Like he was giving, not taking. Like he actually cared.
It wasn’t just the chemistry — though that was very real. It was the way he looked at me, like I wasn’t just a one-time guest. Like I mattered.
We stayed up until the candle I forgot I even lit burned out completely. He held me like he meant it, his hands slow, his voice a whisper against my skin: “You made my night.”
I smiled. “No, Matt....
Read more