Caffè Fiaschetteria Italiana 1888 Srl — Restaurant in Montalcino

Wow, just wow! This is hands down the best spot in Montalcino for an incredible selection of wines. At first glance, it seems quite unassuming, but the moment you step inside, you're transported to a charming 1950s traditional Italian café. Their catalogue of Brunellos is truly impressive, and the prices are remarkably reasonable, especially considering the quality. The service is exceptional, with special mention to Giuseppe, who made the experience even more memorable. The interior is beautifully designed, and the cellar adds a touch of elegance to the atmosphere. The food pairings with each wine were simply perfect. Highly recommend...

Staff were amazing. Had an amazing selection of wines. The venue is very pretty. All the other reviews disagreeing are completely wrong. My favourite bar of my trip to Montalcino, we went here 3 nights in a row. All the bad reviews are uncultured swines. Would recommend to anyone!!

Side note: I speak very little Italian, and the staff were very nice to me, and genuinely cared about the service they gave. Some of these reviews did not give justice at all. The respect you give to staff is the respect you receive. So any reviews disregarding the staff are untrue. And the food is good, and what you would expect from a wine bar, that is not...

Shockingly bad service, particularly the gate keeper attitude to the toilets where you had to wait for permission to use them. Food was insipid and disappointing and we felt really unwelcome. I can only assume we were not the right calaber of clientele as others appeared to be treated differently (i.e. allowed to use the toilet), and this made what should have been a special treat into a thoroughly unpleasant experience. There were clearly others in the restaurant also bemused by the waiting staff's altitude, I hope that they also feel moved to leave a review as only then will...