Supremo's Pizzeria - MARS, PA (ROUTE 228) — Restaurant in Adams Township

Just tried some Supremo's for the first time today for lunch. I am not too familiar with the pizza competition in Mars, or any restaurants in this area for that matter, so I can't say how it compares to other local spots. However, based on the other places I've eaten at near the Pittsburgh area, their pizza is just very average.

Location is somewhat small and in a plaza. I decided to try out the classic cheese pizza (because if you can't nail a delicious cheese pie, you won't nail the more sophisticated pies). The prices are pretty awesome, I will say that. You can get a personal sized pie for just $6, and there is a way to order online from them directly. But, flavor-wise, the food is still pretty mediocre. They have a somewhat thick crust, cheese that's only average, and not enough tomato sauce in my opinion. Nothing stood out, but it wasn't bad. It did have a slightly stale flavor as well.

There are a few interesting items I found on the menu, but didn't order this time. They have nice desserts like the Cookie Bash (tons of chocolate and Oreo) as well as a Mississippi Mudslide Pie (not offered at most pizza places). Plus, the portion for the cinnamon bites is great and it's a great deal!

All in all, this is an alright option for a quick snack, cheap dinner, or event when you need tons of pizza. They are a solid choice for catering or fundraising in the area (if you want cheap pizza, that is). Really good option in terms of prices!

*just saw a notification for the owner’s response - I did not mean the quality was cheap. I meant the prices were cheap, and I don’t think that’s a bad thing? Thanks for clarifying the quality…maybe I just let the pie sit out too long (although I personally don’t think so). Will give an extra star because they actually cared to read...

AVOID. Like many restaurants and pizza dens... good food; terrible service. It's a pity, very good pizza and sandwiches, but the delivery time and management is HORRENDOUS. The last time that I ordered they dropped the ball and it took over 1.5 hours to receive two plain. Just now, I called up asking for a discount, forgetting that the manager had already given us the discount last time and he had the audacity to tell us that the last time we ordered it only took them 29 minutes to deliver (a blatant lie). He contradicted himself, as the last time he admitted to the 1.5 hours of deliver time, yet not tonight. Plus, he gave us the discount last time, so what does that tell you? It's Posti's and Cenci's for me from now on. Skip this joint!

The owner's response below is an ABSOLUTE LIE! Of course he's going to say that. Fraction of a second, get a load of this guy at a pizza shop, now it's nuclear science with bozos delivering their...

I ordered 2 cheese pizzas and a full hoagie club and added bacon. The delivery driver was fast and courteous. The pizzas were REALLY good, but I dont believe I received the right hoagie, and I'm kinda disappointed- it had onions (which I requested not to have on it) and It was covered in Italian dressing. My boyfriend though ate it so it didnt go to waste...but I really wanted a couple bites of it. I would try it again. I did verify with him and he did say yes there was Italian dressing on it ...once I saw the onions I wanted no part of it, I'm picky lol. He said it was really good and I dont know how he could have confused something for for having dressing on it that doesnt. He left my house with only a quarter of it left, if he hasn't finished it I'll have him take a picture and send it to me. Whatever kind of hoagie it was he said he would def eat it again so this mystery...