Mama Mia — Restaurant in Baraboo

Ordered take out from here last night & I felt compelled to write a review! The service was pretty quick! The atmosphere isn't a fancy place, it's definitely like a little hole in the wall mom & pop pizzaria but cozy! We didn't eat there but the place was full of people! The food... wow. SOOO GOOD!! the portions were large! I ordered the Chicken Parm and it was 2 big pieces of chicken with the sauce and noodles, also came with the BEST sourdough dough garlic knot and it was HUGE, also came with a small side salad which was also Wow! Had tomatoes, onions, olives & greens. It was all WONDERFUL I couldn't eat it all! We also ordered the appetizer of the Fried Mushrooms - WOW AGAIN!! they were Whole and light and JUST SOOOO GOOD!! (They did forget our marinara unfortunately but it's ok I had some at home 👍😆). We also ordered the Meatball Parm Sub, it came with a Huge side of fries and hubby said the Sub was GREAT! it was Large and he was only able to eat 75% of it! Overall THIS PLACE IS A MUST!! The ONLY small complaint is their ranch. They gave us a store brand ranch in the little cup that you peel off the foil. That was disappointing- it would be BEST if Mama Mia's made their own ranch because the ranch they give you is HORRID. It doesn't "Go" well with all the WONDERFUL food they serve. That's the only complaint.

We CANNOT wait to come back & try a pizza!!!

Thank you!! Keep up the great food! (But Please! Change your...

I was shopping at the square in Baraboo last Saturday with my kid, when we became very hungry.

We popped in for lunch at Mama Mia without any knowledge of the restaurant. It was about 11:30 am and the dining room was nearly empty, which gave me pause - but the place was very clean and smelled amazing, so we stayed.

There was a pleasant young man who seated us and took our order - while an older employee milled about and chatted with the other customers. I think the "I'm not interested in small talk" vibes I exude were picked up on. Everyone is different, and I understand the intent was positive. I'm cool with servers asking if they can get me anything and if everything is tasting alright, but visiting with strangers isn't for me. Still, not a deal breaker.

Mama Mia's menu has some standard Italian options, but I can't speak to their quality. The pizza is solid A tier, so I might expect the same from their pasta.

There's nothing overly fancy about Mama Mia, and that's perfectly fine. We ordered the smallest size sausage pizza and it was big enough that we took half home. The price, quality and flavor were such that I will...

Not sure what all the good reviews were. We got there 5 of us. Sat at a shotty small booth with a chair at the end. I plan my vacations around 4.5star or better for restaurant reviews. A couple I'm guessing we're regulars there sat about 4mns after us. They got their drink order taken and food taken before we even got our drink order. Cheese bread was good. Mozzarella sticks were ok. The rest of the food was not good. I didn't even finish my meal. Highly disappointed. Meatball sandwich was dry. My chicken was like a frozen chicken breast. Food was not seasoned well. During dinner the guy behind us kept pushing on the booth, we were already irritated with the food being super mediocre. We were ready to GO!! While waiting on the son to retrieve our bill, he sat at a back table we couldn't figure out what was taking so long, mind you there were only 4 tables in there at the time. So when the bill finally came, it was hand-written with each item, yet only a total!! Didn't get a receipt they didn't have any!! I would never recommend...