Sweets on Third — Restaurant in Baraboo

This place is truly a hidden gem on the Court House Square of Baraboo! We were impressed with all of the old soda fountain highlight pieces and the signage describing their history. The location has been beautifully preserved/refreshed. You can almost imagine a soda jerk from the 50's making your order.

Today we were not really hungry and in pursuit of iced coffee, which was brewed fresh, full bodied and wonderful. My one suggestion as someone who drinks the largest size possible and often a refill, 12 and 16 oz cups aren't very much coffee when you add ice. You may want to consider larger sized cups for iced coffee drinks.

Although we did not eat ice cream today, it all looked creamy and decadent. We saw it being ordered as milkshakes, waffle cones, cups, sundaes...The customers that we saw eat it from a 2 year old toddler to an oldster apparently in their 80's, was smiling and enjoying the experience.

The place was lovely, the staff was friendly, patient, accommodating, quick.

If you are looking to support a local business just a short distance from the commercial strip that the Dells has become...head down to Baraboo and enjoy some really good service, an excellent product in a beautiful authentic location!

We will be back for the ice cream, as it looks soo good, and all the comments were that it is excellent. And if you are a coffee drinker, their site roasted beans produce a smooth, bold, balanced flavor that creates an excellent cup...

Stopped by to try it out, but I wasn’t able to as allergens are not taken seriously. Open nut containers are left over the open ice creams with used scoops on the exterior with pieces of nuts left out. Asked if they had any way to get ice cream that wasn’t exposed to the nuts left out/cross contamination and was told they’d use a “clean scoop”. There was not a separate container for allergen-free scoops or the option to pull a scoop from a new tub. These have been the solutions/protocols everywhere else I’ve ever asked due to a possible exposure with no issues. The only other option was a pint (twice the price of what I was planning to get) and there were only 2 options available. My husband was able to get a scoop and said it was great ice cream, just sad I couldn’t get the flavors or...

Treated my little sister to Tin Roof Dairy earlier this week. Never been but was very excited to check it out! Loved their ice cream options and definitely coming back to try their sodas! I was ecstatic when I found out I could order a Blue Moon shake! All the staff were friendly and attentive and made sure we were taken care of even while it was busy. My sister and I thought it was so neat inside and loved reading about the antique bar and soda machine. You can tell the owner, Mike, truly cares about his customers and staff. Definitely recommend going to...