Lenny's Pizzeria & Trattoria — Restaurant in Bernardsville

Can’t go wrong here - Best pizza in this town! Going here for as long as it has been in business. It’s a community staple. Hours of operation are good. It’s always busy during the week and weekends day and evening. Very good food!! No kidding the sauces are delicious! So many styles of pizzas! So many sandwiches and entrees to select from on the grand list of entrees. Food portions are amazing! Can’t finish - take it all home in their containers. They want to make you happy ! Background speaker music is faint and seems like old world Italian tunes. Menus are at each table and they are easy to read . (One thing I will comment on that I don’t prefer or see is large margarita pies pre-made in advance by pizza crew and stacked to go into the oven & exposed to the air etc.. not covered and customers see this stacked display below the counter to the when at cash register.) I think all pizzas are made fresh when ordered. Most recently this restaurant has been updated on the interior of the restaurant. Looks terrific! The menu is really expansive and excellent. Welcoming atmosphere, call your order, or drop in - seems no reservation needed. Hot & cold food, drinks are cold, refrigerator or serve yourself from fountain or the glass case. The place is clean, working crew is polite and easy. Booths accommodate 4, front and back dining-room is accommodating for large groups. In winter don’t sit by the entry it’s a cold draft from customers opening and closing the entry door. CC or cash accepted and waitstaff is very attentive. Parking is avail in large lot in a redesigned shopping center Bernsrdsville PA. You can BYO as well, they will open your bottles or you can ask for an opener. Overall - it’s a family place and neighborhood restaurant that does donuts best to feed you...

2022 - This is a perfect example of why you visit Pizzerias on a yearly basis. Some Places continue to raise the bar, while others go in the other direction. Judging by some of the recent reviews as well, many people feel that the quality has gone down hill. I would agree as these were not the same slices that I had in 2021. The quality was not the same in my 2022 visit. Let me start with the Grandma Slice. The Sauce was way off. Tasted liked it looked, STALE. Now after just paying the bill, and paying $4.10 for 1 slice. Which has to be the most I have paid for a Speciality Grandma Slice ever. The Pepperoni was just a fill your belly Slice. Not sure what happend here, but I will.need to make some adjustments in Somerset County, NJ.

2021 -Margherita Slice was very Good. Good portion slices of Mozarella with a very good tasting sauce. The Crust was good, but could be great. That was the missing component for a 5. Just can't quite put my finger on it, but just needed something more with the crust to put it over the top. Service was average and the place was clean. I...

I've had their white, margarita, ziti, and marinara slices before. I wanted penne vodka pizza, so I ordered a whole pie. What I got looked just like their regular ziti pizza. I asked twice if it was correct because it was made with marinara sauce and not vodka sauce, and they assured me it was, that they just make their penne vodka pizza with regular pizza sauce. The recipe needs to change because this tastes like trash. It is flavorless. I won't be ordering whole pies from here again. It's not worth the price. I also ordered a side of garlic knots and they taste quite stale. The dipping sauce looked more like penne vodka sauce then what was on my pizza. I'm just really disappointed. They're also kind of rude. When I asked if the pizza was correct the response I got was "you ordered penne vodka, this is...