Pizza & Sandwich Barn — Restaurant in Caldwell

It took one 1-1/2 hours to get a sandwich delivered, I ordered on the slice app and obviously my tip was not included even though I did add it in, so when I messaged on the app they told me that my delivery was supposed to be first and he did other deliveries ahead of mine, I’m sure he thought I was going to stiff him so he did my order last , they were able to include the tip after which I should have cancelled, and who the heck puts oregano on a bologna sandwich only you guys, please read the comment when an order is placed online because you never read them, and what a sloppy made sandwich bread was all wet and soggy because you put the pickles in the same wrap as the sandwich, I’m done with Slice and I’m done...

[EDITED BELOW] Waited almost 2 hours for a margherita pizza, garlic knots and Mac & cheese bites. Pizza was awful, no taste whatsoever and was cold. "Garlic" knots didnt even have garlic? Just soft dough in oil. Mac and cheese bites were okay at least but not even warm. So many great spots for pizza in Caldwell, and I wanted to give this place a chance but not again! Wont be ordering again and will be calling tomorrow for a refund.

EDIT: They were prompt with refunding, the very kind and personable delivery man was very sorry...

A classic spot on the main strip. Once you've eaten there, you'll understand why the place has been open for so long. Great offerings for sandwiches and pizza, massive servings. A "full size" sandwich is truly an undertaking, and could likely be enough for both lunch and dinner. Ask the staff for recommendations if the menu seems daunting - I went for a corned beef and turkey with Russian dressing. Definitely stop in if you're a fan of...