Bethlehem Baking Co. — Restaurant in California

I am so happy we decided to go with Bethlehem Baking Co. They were so polite, quick to respond to messages, and easy to work with. All of the cakes were delicious and well decorated. I also feel like it was all very reasonably priced. Most importantly we and our guest loved how delicious the cakes were!

We started out by doing a cake tasting. David and I had a lot of fun discussing the different cake, filling, and frosting options to build our cake tasting box.

We decided to have a small 6 inch couples cake and three half sheet cakes for our wedding. The flavors we used for our wedding were brown butter cake/salted carmel filling/mocha buttercream frosting, lemon cake/vanilla bean cream filling/lemon cream cheese frosting, and vanilla cake/triple berry filling/vanilla...

We ordered 5 dozen cupcakes for my son’s birthday, and they were so delicious! Lovely presentation and very great tasting, too! We got a mix of chocolate and funfetti flavors. For chocolate lovers, these cupcakes were perfect and extra chocolatey! They were a hit with our guests and just what I was looking for at a very reasonable price. Rebekah was sweet enough to add on an extra dozen at the last minute when we ended up having some additional guests, which was so appreciated. The cupcakes disappeared pretty quickly and many people came back for seconds. Wonderful service and amazing cakes! Highly recommend...

My wife Michele and I love Bethlehem Baking Co. We have enjoyed their delicious lemon bars, peanut butter bars, sour dough bread, cookies, and more at several local markets in San Diego. Their Mother's Day boxes were a great gift for moms. Everything we have had was awesome and we look forward to seeing them again in...