Fellinis Pizzeria — Restaurant in Canonsburg

I'm surprised the place is so poorly rated. Yes, the seating isn't that great, and the atmosphere isn't either. But the food itself is quite good. Nothing amazing, but certainly not bad. I tried their plain cheese calzone and a brownie with caramel.

The calzone was quite interesting. It's probably the greasiest calzone I've had in a while, but surprisingly, it was still really good. Most of the grease had already spilled out of the calzone by the time I bit in.

It's topped with a ton of garlic, so the bread part tasted like garlic bread. It was really good. Plus, the calzone was stuffed with an adequate amount of cheese (mozzarella mostly, and a little bit of ricotta as well). Quite good. Portion size was great for the small, and price was around $14 so not too bad. Sauce on the side was sweet but cold when served.

The brownie was really good. It was super fudgey and had large chunks of chocolate scattered throughout it. Very soft. It's absolutely delicious and honestly one of the best brownies I've had in a while. And, it's huge! It's like four brownies in one order for $5.

All in all, I think this place is underrated. Atmosphere isn't the best, but the people are kind (they came out with my food while I was waiting in the car and were courteous). The calzone tasted like a garlic bread with cheese filling and brownie...

So I don’t usually write reviews but this experience was not pleasant. I ordered XL cheese pizza and some wings and was told about 45 minutes. It was over hour before it was actually delivered, which was no big deal things happen. But this is the way the pizza arrived. I told the driver and he called them to have a new one made and delivered. I called them as well and asked if they could just discount the order and we would just make do. I was told that they are not able to discount an order after it was placed (even though they would be able to add a tip on). Then they said they would not be able to even send me a cash refund or mail a check. So they delivered a new pie which they said that it would be 15 minutes. 35 minutes later a delivery driver sheepishly knocked on my door. Just the pie, no coupons or other offerings to make up for the bad pie and having to wait over an hour and 40 minutes to...

The food is good, if it is correct. I called in a pickup order for a buffalo chicken pizza with no onions. I repeated that part at least once because I could hear a lot of yelling in the background. I picked up the pizza, heard more yelling in the background (from the boys in the back making the pizzas) ... Anyway... my order is covered in onions. I proceeded to tell the guys that they'd made a mistake, and that I wanted my money back. They stared at me, then at the computer screen. One of them typed something in, said "you didn't tell me 'no onions.' There's nothing I can do."

Look. Mistakes happen, young men are loud and raucous. I get it. But if my order is wrong, and I demand satisfaction... and your reaction is to imply that I'm either confused or lying... nope. No more. There's no need for me to ever give you my money ever...