C.F. McCarthy’s — Restaurant in Canton

Update: I appreciate the owner response. Kind of sad but they focused only on a couple of elements from my review. They also made assumptions about me and my choices. I even gave props to your food and bartender. I've had plenty of non mass produced beersIPA in Boston and many other cities around the country. $12 is absolutely excessive. You're beers were ok. I'd drink them again but not at $12 when I've had plenty better for prices I mentioned. Sorry that hurts your feelings. For the pizza and pricing. Funny you can list how much it is to add prices to add proteins to a salad but not a pizza. Plus, if you'd of taken the time to really read you'd notice I even asked your bartender. She replied "yes" when I asked if that was any topping. I was just as surprised as you since other pizzas were more. You can easily put the price of each topping in parenthesis next to the topping. Simple formatting will allow you the room. For the beer menu there's plenty of white space to add their prices. I get you're defending your ridiculous pricing but get over yourself. It was good, not earth shattering. I'm not disappointed so no need to be sorry. Good day, mate.

This is another prime example of why places should be required to have prices clearly stated on the menu. Absolute ripoff!!

I will say the food itself was good and the bartender kept up with me regularly even with a fully crowded bar.

The issue is lack of transparency and pricing. I ordered the custom pizza and nowhere on your menu does it State you would be charged for each topping you order. It clearly says start by choosing your cheese and then your toppings. I even asked the bartender does this include any of the toppings I choose and she stated yes. So I ordered the pizza and that you can clearly see on my receipt I was charged for each and every topping on top of the price of the pizza. No way in the world it was worth that kind of money. The other issue with pricing is on your beers. $12 for a small draft? You have to be kidding! Average ipas for this size I can get almost anywhere aside from a concert or the airport for 7 to $8. This should have been clearly posted on the menu. I'm sure a popular comeback is well you should have asked but as a customer you shouldn't have to. This made for a completely terrible experience when I received my receipt to see I had been charged over $50 for a $25 meal.

Beware before you go if you do. Be sure to ask for complete price transparency in anything that you order. No way I would ever come back to this place at these...

Ok right off the bat, my wife and I live right up the street and have always said we were going to give it a try one night.

Best decision....ever, no exaggeration whatsoever. Haven't felt so comfortable somewhere like this in a long time....like home.

From the moment we walked in, clean establishment, really cool vibe, eye contact and service with a smile from every staff member we came in contact with. A huge THANK YOU to the Hostess who had no issue with giving us a table after we changed out minds from the high tops for more of an intimate setting.

Once re-seated Umaka greeted us. Our drinks were, for lack of a better word......PERFECT.

For food we decided on appetizers and a salad or "bowl" . The fish tacos were amazing. The fish was cooked perfectly. The avacado was beyond fresh. Add the sour cream and pickled onion and....wow, just wow.

After taking a bite of the Dry Rub Wings, I simply looked at my wife with a smile and said...

"Ok, now they're just showing off!"

No need to request "well done" at all. Just so damnit good.

Babe ordered the Fiesta Bowl with Chicken. Everything about this salad was so fresh and clean tasting, add this to what ill be ordering when we come back.

High five Mary, we all shared a laugh when she walked by and immediately noticed our drinks were empty and went into semi-panic mode wanting to replace them. Umaka was already on the mission to get the second round. A thousand stars for their overall attentiveness as well.

Seriously looking forward to our second and hopefully regularly visit to CF MCCarthys. If I could give you 20 Stars I would. You have...

The wait staff and bartender were fabulous. The atmosphere was ok, lots of smiles from waitress, and hostess was accommodating. We (party of 3) asked to be moved from the bar to a table and it was no problem. The food on the other hand was just ok, and at these prices, that's not ok. I ordered the "grass fed rib eye tips" . The owner or manager are perpetrating an out and out bait and switch on this one. My order of tips came out slightly warm, and drenched in some drab boring tasteless sauce called "sweet bourbon glaze". These tips WERE NOT rib eye tips. I'm not even sure they are sirloin tips. I know "steak tips" is a generic term and could be meat from any of several cuts. But if you're going to call them "rib eye" tips, they should come from the rib area, where rib eye steak comes from. My suspicion was confirmed by an employee, I don't want to get them in trouble, so I can't say who. I sent the order back and was given another item, which was overcooked. I ordered the black rice, was undercooked and like eating sand, the spinach was the best thing we had. They know their not serving rib eye quality tips, just take it off the menu. Either the chef or the manger owes everyone that's ever ordered this an apology. Would not recommend. Seriously, I don't know where all these 5 star...