Oddfellows Restaurant — Restaurant in Chagrin Falls

We’ve been here twice - once for brunch and the other for dinner. Brunch was quiet for a Saturday and so was dinner on a Thursday night. They don’t have outdoor seating :/ Brunch was okay, I got the burger which had a nice flavor but the burger was a bit dry (I got it medium well). Fries were a good balance of crispy and soft. The steak and potatoes were a solid choice as well but would have been better with an egg. The cinnamon rolls were big - one of ours was burnt and they gladly got us a new one.

Our dinner experience was fantastic! The shishito peppers had an amazing flavor, I don’t think we got any spicy ones - but we understand it’s chance and the vinegarette was so flavorful, we didn’t mind. The tomato bisque was fine - nothing unique and for $12 it would be a pass for next time. I got the bBell & Evans Chicken (definitely got for the full portion if you are hungry) and the mashed potatoes. Both were very flavorful and the chicken had a nice crisp and was still moist. While the menu didn’t state it, our server was upfront about the up-charges for certain sides. My partner ordered the short ribs and was able to sub the risotto for carrots. The short ribs were okay - not as tender as we would want and I was not a fan of the demi flavor, but he would order it again. The carrots were so unique with pistachio and pomegranate topping - they were also cooked for perfection. Cute restaurant, hope they continue to do well,...

From the moment you step into Oddfellows in Chagrin Falls, you know you're in for a special dining experience. The ambiance is warm and inviting, with a perfect blend of rustic charm and modern elegance. The staff are exceptionally attentive and knowledgeable, making sure every detail of your meal is perfect.

The menu is a delightful mix of inventive and classic dishes, each prepared with meticulous care and fresh, high-quality ingredients. The appetizers, particularly the mussels, are a fantastic start to the meal. For the main course, the chef’s special—whether it’s a perfectly seared steak or a delicately prepared seafood dish—never fails to impress. And don’t miss the desserts; they are truly the cherry on top of an already incredible dining experience.

What sets Oddfellows apart is not just the food but the overall atmosphere and service. It’s clear that this restaurant is dedicated to providing a memorable experience, whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or just enjoying a night out. For anyone in or visiting Chagrin Falls, Oddfellows is a must-visit dining destination that stands out for its exceptional quality and genuine...

My husband and I visited Oddfellows on 2/14/2025 for last minute Valentine’s Day dinner. A friend recommended this place and I’m sooooo glad they did. The food was probably common the best I’ve had in LONG time. The lamb and chicken were so flavorful. The onion rings were seasoned to perfection, the Mac and cheese was delectable, and the crab dip was delicious. My husband and I were savoring every bite. It was so good that we are going to come back with our friends in a couple of weekend. I saw this place a few months back and put it on our list as a place to eventually visit, but I’m so glad we got the opportunity to try it because we left speechless.

The pricing is fair, we didn’t feel like it was a price gouge or that it was overpriced. With it being in Chagrin Falls, we definitely feel like the prices are comparable to any other restaurant but with WAAAAY better food!

My only gripe is that we sat near the door and any time someone came in and out we would cringe at the bitter cold air that followed. But, regardless, we are going to return because the food...