Cristy's Pizza Circleville — Restaurant in Circleville

Listen, the pizza is very good, so I can’t give lower than 4 stars. And I know why some pizza places do this but they put the pepperoni UNDER the cheese. Yes, it’s supposed to make the sauce taste better but the difference is hardly noticeable and nobody appreciates the subtle difference because it’s…. Subtle… and we are just hungry, not pizza sauce connoisseurs.

I bought a pepperoni pizza because one person likes pepperoni but the three including me who normally pick it off couldn’t. So they ate something else.

I won’t be going back for this one reason.

I’d also like to add… the crispy edges of the pepperoni that is put on top of the cheese is 10000x better than any advantage cooking it under the cheese gives. Not a good trade off if you ask me.

At the very least if you’re going to run a pizza place and go with the bad and unpopular decision to place the pepperoni under the cheese, put a note/warning so people who are expecting to pick off the pepperoni aren’t screwed when the...

First time ever eating this pizza and was reluctant because I thought the prices were a little steep. I finally broke down and tried it since Circleville don't have many options. I ordered the Classic with extra cheese and chose to pick it up. The store was clean and the two employees were friendly. I was first impressed when the pizza was handed to me because it was heavy. Heavy means a lot of toppings. When I got home and took a bite, I was very impressed. The crust was almost perfect with that slight crisp on the underside. The sauce was one of the best with a slight sweetness which took away the acidity - good thinking! The toppings were fresh and also delicious. I've ate pizza from all over and this one ranks at the top. The point system is also a good ideal and I would have given 5 stars but took one away because of the price, which even as good as it was, was a little too high. Overall... excellent pie and excellent establishment and...

First they deliver the wrong order to our home. Then when we notify them at 6:42 the boy said the driver was turning around. However, 14 minutes later at 6:56, the driver answered the phone and said he had forgotten the salads and was leaving the store with them now. But clearly both times they lied. As it turns out the order sent to our home that was wrong had the name and number on their receipt. When I called them, they said yes it was delivered to their home and that because they couldn't get nobody on the phone they took our order back to the store themselves. So clearly this is pure incompetence at its finest. So clearly upset the 2nd time the punk calls me back clarifying my order laughing about it and I told him to cancel my order. To which he hung up on me. I will never go to this store again and will visit the corporate office myself later this week... These people have no business in customer...