New York Bagel — Restaurant in City of Cortland

It was a cool Sunday afternoon in April, when I found myself drawn to the idea of a toasted bagel sandwich, So with visions of glistening melted cheese and crisp toasted deliciousness I walked into the New York Bagel, I was taken back by the amount of people in line ahead of me, and nearly turned around to leave, but the promise of local bagel heaven was to much to turn down. The line moved quickly and I soon found myself at the counter ready to place my order. "1 Italian sandwich" I proclaimed, to which the man behind the counter responded "we only have whole wheat bagels right now", I stammered momentarily unsure what to make of the situation, as the line of hungry college students grew behind me, It was then that the man behind the counter suggested I try the sandwich as a wrap, I agreed, and he took my name, and handed me my slip. As I waited for my wrap I took note of the eating area, very few tables occupied the small establishment, each of which seated 4 people comfortably, there was a stair case leading down, though I did not get an opportunity to explore as my name was promptly called for wrap. Tightly twisted inside the green spinach tortilla were 3 meats, tomatoes, lettuce, and, cheese, however it was hard to distinguish between the various flavors as the salami was cut as thick as $.75 worth of quarters stacked together, which would have been amazing on a bagel, but only proved a challenge in a wrap, the tomatoes were juicy and the tortilla was fresh, an overall enjoyable wrap, though I'm not going to go out of my way to spend another $7+ on it. Overall if not for the wonderful service I may have given my experience 3 stars, but good customer service and presentation are far more rare than an over priced wrap with 8oz...

Under construction so seemed a bit dark. Had a Begal with butter on one side cream cheese on the other. Definitely was lacking but I guess I wouldn't have expected them put back together.. was disappointed in the bagel Update... construction done! Still lots of noise from behind the counter.. made the meeting I was at hard to hear.. food about the same but seemed fresher this time New update, I went back since I had a gift certificate... It was not as loud .. the Food 100% better and tasted good just a bit on the slow side but I take that for the good fresh taste. Just make sure you...

Coffee was amazing, breakfast sandwich was meh. Sandwich had frozen sausage, overcooked egg, bagel barely toasted so it didn't hold together well at all. Bf got some bottled grape juice that was very nearly wine, but had no expiration date on the bottle. Staff was curt and didn't give welcoming vibes. Waited 40 minutes for our order. Haven't tried the lunch or dinner options. The bagels we're great and the cream cheese was good. We'll probably try again another day.

Tldr: but the bagels with cream cheese or the coffee. Avoid the...