Black Dog Pizzeria — Restaurant in Columbus

Wow. Just wow. Let me tell you somethin. I eat a lot of pizza. Like, I eat SO much pizza, I have to lie to my physician about it (bro knows the truth tho, cause when he test my blood he be like “yo this is marinara, you are sickkkk” but that’s neither here nor there)… I eat PIZZA.

I discovered Black Dog Pizza last year, and OMG it made my taste buds feel like they were kids again hangin out at DZ Discovery Zone (on Brice Rd, real ones know what I’m talking about). Shortly after my relationship started with Black Dog, Ryu apparently decided to visit and do a Hadoken in the kitchen… which resulted in a temporary shut down of operations (I was always partial to Mortal Kombat anyway, thanks Ryu!).

But NOW they have reopened. It’s like Black Dog II: The Barkquel with the ORIGINAL CAST from the first movie SO YOU KNOW ITS GONNA BE A BANGER.

And let me tell you, it’s better than the original. My tastebuds squealed when I popped a slice of that Black Dog pizza into my mouth. The old world pepperonis, SO crunchy. SO delicious. The crust?! OMG crispy and amazing. The SAUCE?! ITS PART of my blood stream. And the Benji… just like our hero pup from Disney, this pizza could dodge a cougar, run across fallen trees, and swim across rivers… ITS brave. It’s brilliant. I WANT MORE.

I see these reviews giving 1 star. And it’s wild. I seriously don’t know how it’s possible. The owners are two of the raddest pizza owners in Columbus. If somethin is amiss with your pie, they will TOTALLY make it right, I have no doubt about it.

If you enjoy movies like Homeward Bound, CUJO, Face/Off, Con Air, The Rock, Strays, and Milo and Otis… you will freakin LOVE Black Dog Pizza!!!!!

YO GET THEIR PUPPERONI CUP TOO 😂😂😂

i added banana peppers to my Black Dog pizza so please don’t let that scare you

And if you like movies like Gigli, Justin and Kelly, Grown Ups 2, or Kirk Cameron’s Saving Christmas, consider cooking some unflavored rice and chicken for...

I made a “central Ohio pizza tour” booklet/passport thing at the beginning of the year, and when I was researching which places to add, Black Dog Pizzeria kept popping up in everyone’s recommendations.

We stopped in on a Saturday, right when they opened, but the door was locked! Sad! But then the clouds parted, angels sang, and the door was opened by none other than the owner himself (I’ll call him Dave, hey Dave!) (yes, I know his name is actually Nick). He was so welcoming and just an all-around awesome dude. Now, don’t go in expecting to sit and eat. We definitely expected that. There’s one table, Tony said we could totally hang out and eat, but I think it’s really just for folks to sit at while waiting for their carry out orders to be ready. That said, there’s a million things to look at on the walls, most of it is art made by customers! Pizza/dog themed art! It’s incredible. And there’s an awesome hand-painted mural that was done by a customer, too. Such a neat way to decorate 🍕🐕‍🦺

So Dave walked us through the menu, gave us a bit of history about the place as we needlessly deliberated about what to order. See, to give an equal opportunity to each place, we always order a basic pepperoni and cheese. We figure, if you can’t do a classic pep & cheese justice, can you really call yourself a pizza joint?!

Well, no worries for black dog. They can DEFINITELY call themselves a pizza joint. This thing came out of the oven smelling divine, like the Sicilians of Italy met up with the cheeseheads of Wisconsin and made a perfect little aromatic potpourri of pizza goodness.

Cheese pull: 8/10 Crust: 10/10 Toppings: 10/10 Sauce: 9/10 Ambiance: 15/10 Customer service: 19/10 Overall: yes. Go there. Order everything. See the “oh my goddddd this pizza is amazing” picture below!

We liked it so much that we actually went back that same night and got a...

Terrrible dont waste your time....they will mess your whole order up and tell you oh well....worst customer service of any place ive ordered from......seeee the response???? They dont take ownership of anything even the owner....i dont care about your 25$ pizza its the point you meseed my order up....maybe if you would stay off replying to reviews and watching the brady bunch while at work you would get your orders right......its def a review look at the owner acts goes to sleep running his mouth wakes up running his mouth....why dont u ask jessica if her order was correct last night since her receipt was in my bag????....why did u edit your response from last night????your whole message is diff.....def going to the better buisness bureau.....and still have the receipt that says jessica on it delivered by doordash when i ordered from ubereats so guess im not the only ones order u messed up last night...to busy on your phone being a tough guy.....u sound even dumber then the tough guy that answered the phone...sooo doordash is the one that puts garlic knots in a bag instead of a salad doordash is the ones that i didnt even order from but still have the receipt for jessica?? I ordered from ubereats how do i have a receipt for jessica that ordered from doordash???? Let me guess not your fault either.....i have pictures receipts screenshots dates times i already sent to the bbb so keep telling me im lying and scamming.. your whole buisness already posted 3 diff responses u edit everyone why u feel the need???...