Geno Nottolini's Pizza — Restaurant in Elgin

this used to be a great place. but just recently they jacked their prices up and started getting cheap and skimping on quality and quantity. we got a 14 inch thin crust with three ingredients... it was NOT 14 inches.. more like 12 1/2.. and an order of boneless BBQ chicken wings..

the "wings" were NOT real chicken but basically chicken McNuggets smothered in BBQ sauce.. there was hardly any sausage or spinach on the pizza, and the total was $50.. $50 for a twelve-ish inch pizza and some McNuggets???!! Really?!

Way way overpriced. They are really cheapskates and skimping on ingredients and quantity. We will NOT be ordering from...

This is my first time ordering from this restaurant and it will be a forever going on thing!!! I just moved to Elgin and I've been trying out the different pizza places in the area, I found a couple good ones but Geno's is the best and I'm not going to search anymore, I found my pizza place!! I also ordered the spaghetti marinara but I didn't have a chance to try it yet because the pizza got me so full. Can't wait to try the pasta tomorrow. Thanks for being so good. Looking forward to trying other pizzas from you. The crust is perfect, the cheese is yummy and just enough sauce makes the pizza...

I am a frequent customer and this is the only place I buy my pizza, but I was dissatisfied with the service tonight. I typically buy thin crust pizza, but this time I decided to try the "stuffed crust pizza” which anyone will assume it means cheese-filled crust, but when it arrived, it was a deep dish pizza, which I have never liked because of the overwhelming amount of cheese. The title on the menu is misleading. I called to inform them of the mistake and whether I could get credit or a refund, but all I was told was to "call back on Monday, I’m not the manager." I will NOT...