Eatalia Pizza — Restaurant in Elmwood Park

I was excited to order from here because it is very close to where I live. The pizza here was SUPER thin, like paper thin. I even picked up a slice from my pie, and another slice rolled over. I think the pizza was under cooked. But none the less, it was extremely thin. The wings were okay, and my cold sandwich was good. The bread my sandwich was made with was very fresh and it was a good portion size. I do want to give this place another shot though... I think I may try to get another sandwich, a hot sandwich, and if it's good I will order sandwiches from here, but I don't think the pizza makes the cut for us. I was surprised, actually, because it looked like the prepared pizzas on display were of normal thickness. Did we just...

This afternoon was the first time I stopped in at Eatalia to try the pizza. I was in the mood for a personal cheese pizza with extra cheese. Well the gentleman who made the pizza fulfilled my request and did not disappoint. He was very kind and didn't even charge me for the extra cheese. I told him I'd write a review after trying the pizza. I decided on take out and enjoyed my personal cheese pizza at home. It was absolutely delicious. I highly recommend Eatalia in Elmwood Park to anyone who loves pizza. The service is wonderful and the pizza is as well. I look forward to returning to try something else on...

We ordered two pies and only received one. The delivery guy checked the order and went to get the other pie and bring it back. He brought back a smushed up pie. It looked as if someone sat on the box of the pizza. Grease and cheese all over the inside of the box. Very disappointing. 4.75 for delivery and tipped the delivery driver 9 dollars. Guess he got his money and could care...