Cute Mom & Pop meets hometown Calico Cupboard type feel here. Falls short of 5 stars for me for a few reasons, but I would definitely return to give it more chances to earn 5 stars!

I've had their burgers, sandwiches, salads, peach pie a la mode and cookies/bars. Burgers and sandwiches are delicious and well done, with a fresh mixed greens salad side. Portions are good. Salad, which fresh, is topped with some sort of raspberry (?) vinaigrette dressing. Very light, but could use another topping like cucumber, tomatoes, carrots, etc. just to add a little more to it. Went back one time after eating our meals to order peach pie a la mode. It might have been an off day, but the guy forgot to bring it out. When he did, he did apologize and said he got caught up in other things, but the pie was cold (I did just assume it would be warmed and didn't ask for it to be heated) and the "a la mode" was a sad tiny two spoonfuls of ice cream. Taste was OK, but generally put tastes 1000% better heated, don't you agree? Since it had taken so long, and it came a la mode, I didn't bother to ask for it to be heated. Maybe next time. The peanut bar was tasty - not overly sweet. and lots of peanuts on top - kind of like pecan pie, but with peanuts and no crust!

Ordering at the counter and getting your own silverware and seating yourself is OK. There have always been tables available (4 seaters all around and a few in the middle for larger groups). I like that there is alwaya self-serve iced water (with lemon slices) available near the order counter.

I think the ambiance could be slightly improved if they could paint the sides of the concrete building next door, as several tall windows in the dining area look straight into these blank, grey walls (only a few feet from the windows) as the only view.

There are separate men's and women's coded entry bathrooms in the back that I think are shared with the Co-Op next door. Clean but older and smaller, 2 stalls but only 1 sink.