Chicago's Pizza Fishers — Restaurant in Fishers

I just had the pleasure of ordering some takeout from here and was pleasantly surprised. I got "The Big Hurt" deep dish pepperoni pizza, which was fantastic, and was enough to feed four people. I'm pretty picky with pizza and this was perfect. I also got the garlic cheese bread, which was pretty good. The staff was friendly, efficient, and really helped us out when ordering for The first time. The only things I could see needing any improvement would maybe be the interior (it's a bit sparse but there is lots of room to move around) and making the beer selections more easily accessible. However, this location just opened so I'm sure things will continue to improve as they get settled in. Needless to say, I definitely see this place becoming one of my...

I picked up an order from the McCordsville location for DoorDash and it smelled so good that I had to try it myself from the one closer to me(this one).

I was not disappointed at all. They followed the special instructions I added and when my husband picked it up they had him check it to make sure they got it right. Honestly the best pizza I've had in a good while. The breadsticks were really good too.

The only criticism I have is I wish they put just a bit more of each topping on. But they charge less for additional toppings than most places so it's kind of a decent trade off there. I'm sure I could order double toppings if I wanted more of something.

I will definitely be ordering again. You've got a new...

This is Absolutely the Worst Pizza that I’ve Ever Received!! I Arrived a Few Minutes Early to Pick the Pizza Up. The staff at the register stated that the pizza was fresh out of the oven. The pizza looked like it was left from the night before. Unbelievably Disappointed!!! When asked to speak with a Manager the employee went looking for the manager. She returned stating that she could not find her!! Being New to this Area, this is the absolute worst experience and the worst management ever. Definitely does not rank up to “High Quality” by ANY Means!!! Even after calling and requesting to speak with the owner or highest level of management, I never received the courtesy of a...