Pizzeria showcasing thoughtfully sourced ingredients in its inventive, homemade pies.
Learn more insights from Wanderboat AI.
Coconino Skatepark (The Basin)
4.3
(11)
Polibertos
4.4
(543)
Brandy's Restaurant & Bakery
4.4
(688)
Las Gorditas Mexican Food
4.6
(484)
$
Little Caesars Pizza
3.9
(296)
I truly pray that I receive an equally unprofessional response as the last guy who left an HONEST review.
Before reading further just know you are better off with the 3 small pizzas from a lunchable.
If an owner takes the time out of their day to respond to a review because they got their wittle feelings hurts, it’s because that review had truth.
By far the worst food I’ve experienced in my life, and I’ve eaten bugs! This place is expensive and not at all worth it. For 2 16” pizzas and 2 dozen wings the bill came out to $120. Then the delivery itself was a 2 hr wait. At first I didn’t mind the wait because reviews mentioned a long wait but delicious taste. Delivery guy also said that the place is slow but good. Is New Jersey Pizza Co. paying everyone to lie? Or are they holding their families hostage? Did I miss the secret code to receive actual good food?
God awful greasy limp pizza. The wings? Tiny, dry and too much vinegar. After everyone had a serving, not that it could be finished, this was all thrown into the trash
If you want your tastebuds to be offended and appalled then this is the trash for you. I’m convinced it’s children held captive being forced to cook the pizza because the pizza tastes like its secret...
Read more
A Perfect Wedding Anniversary Spot – 10/10 Would Recommend!
My wife and I decided to celebrate our wedding anniversary at New Jersey Pizza Company in Flagstaff, Arizona, and it was one of the best decisions we’ve ever made. We specifically chose this place after hearing great things, and it truly lived up to the hype!
From the moment we walked in, we could feel the passion and commitment the owner has for this place. The story behind the restaurant was touching, and you can tell the heart and soul that goes into everything they do. The food? Absolutely incredible. The pizza and wings were some of the best we’ve ever had. Every bite was full of flavor, and you could tell the ingredients were top-notch. We were so impressed we left a heavy tip—partly because we were in love with the food, but also because we were in awe of the dedication and love the owner pours into this business.
Ten out of ten, we would highly recommend this spot to anyone. Honestly, if I could, I’d give them a Michelin star! LOL. This place is a must-visit, and we can’t wait to come back for another memorable meal.
Thank you, New Jersey Pizza Company, for making our...
Read more
New Jersey Pizza Co. is the best pizza in Flagstaff and it is not even close. It is equal with the best pizzas my wife and I have had in many different cities around the world. The cheese bread sticks are the best we have ever had, no comparison. Then there is the hummus! You have to have this hummus. We have traveled to all the areas of the world where hummus is a staple and the hummus at NJPC is equal to or better than any hummus we have tried. It is heavenly! The pickled veggies that come with it, the bread, the creaminess of the hummus.....perfection!
The food takes a long time to cook but it is always worth it. I will say, it is hard to take our young kids there because it does take a long time to get the food. Plan ahead knowing that you will wait longer than any other restaurant you have been too. Don't come here if you don't have extra time. If you go in with this expectation, you will have a great time and you will enjoy incredible food.
This place is on a different level than any other restaurant in Flagstaff. It is worth the wait and it gives you time to enjoy time with your spouse, family, or friends...
Read more
